nec load analysis question

Nov 16, 2006 2 Replies

I am currently studying for the journeyman exam using "Stallcup's Journeyman Electrician's study guide". I am currently in chapter 10: Commercial calculations. Whenever my answer differed from the books I re-read the nec and I would find my error. However now I can't see why my answers are wrong. I have two questions:


1) in a commercial building ( say 120/240 V single phase three wire ) where the service load calculations for the neutral is greater that 200 A shouldn't article 220.61(B)(2) apply?


2) in the book there are examples of the following:



store building: 277/480 V 3 phase



  1. office area is 277 V lighting
  2. warehouse area is 277 V lighting

various 480 V loads



  1. various 120 V lighting loads ( track lighting, outside lighting, show window lighting, etc)
  2. various 120 V receptacle loads ( multioutlet assemblies, continuous and non continuous receptacle loads, etc )

For the neutral, the book adds the VA of 1,2, and 3. It then divides this by



480*sqrt(3). Why didn't they add the load of 4 as well? The examples do not mention any type of transformer and I am at a loss as to why they would include the 120 V lighting but not the 120 V receptacle load in the neutral calculations?


Thank you for your time.



Note: If the book happens to be in error does anyone know where I can find the corrections posted? ( I have searched but found nothing ).


James Stallcup will be the first to tell you that no book is without errors.

. . . .

I am only trying to find the correct way to do the calculations. It's more than likely that I am the one in error and I wish to know why.

thank you

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required