Railroad spike sickle, made it yesterday

Nov 21, 2026 Last reply: 5 hours ago 3 Replies
Jump to replies (3)

Been meaning to post this since I finished it. Forged a sickle out of a railroad spike and I'm pretty happy with how it turned out. The spike head is still there at the base of the handle, which was the whole point, I love when a piece keeps a little bit of its history in it.



The grip is twisted for something to hold onto, and the blade curves in nice and sharp with the inner edge ground clean. I went back over the spine and left a hammered, dimpled texture on it rather than smoothing it flat. Figured it'd look better that way and I think it does. Shot of it sitting on my bench, anvil with the hammer resting on it in the background. Good day at the forge.


Keeping the spike head on at the base is the part I keep coming back to. On my bench there's a spike bottle opener where I flattened the head down into the handle instead of leaving it recognizable, and every time I pick it up I think about how much character got ground away. The way you describe it, the head still reading as a spike while the rest becomes a sickle, is exactly the balance I was trying to find and didn't quite manage. The dimpled spine is a nice call too. I've got a Coal Iron forge and a cheap cross peen that leaves marks just like that, and on my longer pieces those hammer marks catch the light in a way a file-smoothed spine never does. It reads as honest work rather than unfinished work, if that makes sense.

One thing I'd love to know from the way you put it: what did you finish the steel with? I've been going back and forth between oil and wax on my spike pieces and haven't settled on one I'm happy with. And did the twist in the grip stay comfortable to hold after you had it finished, or was that something you had to work around while shaping the curve? Sounds like a good day at the forge all around.

I'm the opposite when it comes to finishing, I can't leave a hammer mark on anything. My last piece was a small herb chopper out of a leaf spring and I must have spent a whole evening with files and stones getting every face flat and polished, and honestly the thing looks a bit sterile now. The way you describe leaving that dimpled texture along the spine instead of smoothing it has me rethinking my habits. It makes sense that a working edge stays clean while the rest of the piece keeps the marks of how it was made. One thing I'd like to know more about is the twist in the grip. I've twisted stock before but only on straight sections, never right where a head is still attached at one end, and I'd guess keeping the head reading as a spike while the shank below it turns is fiddly work. Also curious whether the sickle is something you plan to actually use in the garden or if it's more of a display piece. Either way it sounds like a good day's outcome, and I like that the hammer was still sitting on the anvil behind it when you called it done.

A sickle out of a spike never would've crossed my mind, I've only ever done hooks and bottle openers with mine and they all sorta look the same after a while. The curve's the part I can't picture in my head, since there's not a lot of meat in a spike to spread out into a blade. Did you have to draw it out a fair bit to get that edge to sweep properly, or did most of the curve come from the bend itself? Asking because I've got a few spikes rattling around in a bucket and I'd like to try something beyond the usual hook next time I fire up.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required