Found out why the holes were coming out shallow, and honestly I just had to laugh

Nov 22, 2026 Last reply: 5 hours ago 4 Replies
Jump to replies (4)

Spent part of my morning working through a handwritten note that got left for me on the workbench. The guy I work with, 30 years in this trade, has been struggling with drilled holes not coming out deep enought. So he edited line N55 and changed Z6.3 to 6.8, thinking that whould fix it.



Except that line isn't the drill depth. It's the retract. All he did was move where the tool pulls back to, and the actual depth never changed. Then he wrote the whole thing out in red ink explaining the depth wouldn't respond, like the control was just ignoring him. Holes still shallow, note still sitting there, me just staring at it. And here's the part that gets me. This is close to a daily occurrence at this point. I'm tired, boss.


I've watched this exact dynamic play out where I work. There's a fella here with close to three decades on manual lathes and mills, and by hand he can turn out beautiful work, but the moment he has to touch a program he's lost. He got moved onto the CNC side when the shop brought those machines in and never really got shown how the code works, so he's been guessing his way through ever since. Great on a handwheel, helpless in front of a screen.

What I've come to understand from watching guys like him is that years on the job only measure time, not learning. Some fellas run the same few parts on the same machine for a decade and that corner of the shop is their entire world. Sit them down in front of a program and it might as well be a foreign language. Your coworker editing the pull-back value instead of the depth value reads exactly like someone who never learned what those numbers do, only memorized which spot to poke at when something went wrong.

One thing in his favor, I suppose. He at least wrote out what he did and left it for you instead of shrugging and walking off. The guy I deal with usually says nothing and I find out at inspection.

And I hear you on being worn down. Daily is a brutal pace to absorb that kind of thing.

The part that wears on me in situations like yours isn't even the wrong edit, it's the confidence behind it. When someone with that many years in the trade writes it all out in red ink like the machine is misbehaving, they genuinely belive they diagnosed somethig. That's harder to argue with than plain confusion, beacuse now you're not correcting a keystroke, you're correcting a whole story they've alredy written down. I've ended up being the guy people hand thier head-scratchers to at my shop, and what I started doing is just reading the program myself before anyone touches it. If a number looks like it's in the wrong block, I say so before chips fly. It's not glamorous but it beats finding out at the inspection bench. For what it's worth, the note habit isn't the worst thing in the world. I'd rather get a handwritten explanation of what somebody changed than find out they fiddled with the program and said nothing. At least with the note you can trace exactly where the thinking went sideways and walk them back to it. Honestly though, if this is a near-daily thing for you, the tiredness makes total sense. Being the unofficial decoder for a veteran who won't ask questions in the moment is its own kind of job, and nobody's paying you for it.

Back on the manual floor you'd holler across the shop and somebody'd come over, put a hand on your shoulder, and show you the thing once. Nobody left essays in red ink pinned to the bench. The way you tell it, a fella who'll write out a whole explanation instead of just asking has got to be embarrassed, and embarrassed men dig in rather than admit they're guessing.

Have you considered sitting down with him once and walking the program through, line by line, quiet, no audience? He obviously wants those holes right or he wouldn't keep coming back to it day after day. Real question is whether he'd take it from you or decide he's being talked down to by the young fella. Which way does he lean?

Update: read through the replies a few times now. The one about the old manual floor guys hollering across the shop instead of leaving essays in red ink stuck with me. Feels like pride more than anything else at play here. Honest question for you all, has anyone actually got a coworker like this to ask for help, or does trying just make them dig in harder?

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required