1x30 belt sander for sharpening

A couple of weeks ago, I picked up a Harbor Freight 1x30 belt sander, for w
hich I had a coupon. Total price was under 30 bucks.
I bought a leather belt
formatting link

I also bought a 120 grit belt (finest grit I could find locally) and have o
rdered some finer belts (up to 800) which should be here in a few days.
I tried a couple of kitchen knives with the 120 followed by leather. HOLY C
RAP! I have been sharpening knives for 40+ years, and i'm impressed. While
the 120 belt left some noticeable "grain," the edge is nothing short of sha
rp. It shaves easily, and slices vegetables, meat and paper like a sharp kn
ife should.
The truly amazing part is that the whole process took less than five minute
s. A proper progression through successive grits, say 120, 240, 320, 400 sh
ouldn't take any longer and will yield a prettier (if not more functional)
edge.
Y'all may want to give this a try.
Reply to
rangerssuck
Loading thread data ...
I have used my 1x30 HF belt sander for sharpening before as well. Its not bad for quickly reshaping a badly dulled blade, but if you look at it under a magnifier you will see its more a series of ragged teeth than a sharp edge. Even for a steep angle blade like an axe head it will dull quickly if its left like that. A good edge still needs to be finished on a fine stone for long holding.
I made much the same discovery you did a few years ago, and I proudly announced it here on RCM where several members promptly set me straight. Rather than argue I both tested it, and I looked at it under a microscope as compared to a blade finished on the fine stone of the triple oil stone I have left over from my youth cutting meat in my Mom's grocery store.
That being said, I still occasionally throw a quick edge on a blunt tool with the belt sander.
Also, be aware with thin blades and thin tips that it will overheat the steel very very quickly.

Reply to
Bob La Londe
Yeah, I figured it's a pretty ragged edge, based on the coarseness of the b elt. I expect that the edge will be much cleaner and prettier with a finer belt before the leather. That said, I wouldn't really care if there were di nosaur teeth on the edge - it's sharp enough to shave and slices carrots, p otatoes and ripe tomatoes cleanly and easily.
As far as overheating, with a proper progression of grits and with reasonab le care, that shouldn't be a problem. You wouldn't want to try to remove 80 grit scratches with a 400 grit belt - it would take too long and likely ov erheat. But go through, say, 120, 220, 320 and THEN 400, and it should only take a few passes on each belt.
The jury's still out on this. I'll know more in a few days after the belts get here. But for now, it's looking pretty good.
When you did your test, what grit belts did you use? I saw one youtube vide o that suggested 80 grit and then leather, and that's it.
Reply to
rangerssuck
When you did your test, what grit belts did you use? I saw one youtube video that suggested 80 grit and then leather, and that's it.
I used 80/120/240... My test basically showed with a regular "working" it didn't seem to hold up very long. I am sure with a finer grit it would be less course and hold up longer, but instead I just used it for really bad blades and finished them on the stone after that.

Reply to
Bob La Londe
"Bob La Londe" fired this volley in news:li4pa9$rq9$ snipped-for-privacy@dont-email.me:
Y'know, we get all sorts of arguments about what is the sharpest blade... but when it comes to cutting veggies, I personally want a slight bit of a rough, wire edge. It handles fibrous stuff so much better than even a razor edge does. (otherwise, why not cut trees down with straight razors, neh?)
I'm partial to carbon steel kitchen blades, and I sharpen those to a wire edge, while honing my SS kitchen knives to smooth edges. That way it's easy to tell them apart at a glance.
For the wire edge, I stop at 150, then use a light touch on a hard fabric dressing wheel to take just the loose burrs off, but leave a bit of the 'sawtooth'.
LLoyd
Reply to
Lloyd E. Sponenburgh
Really? Yer gonna give me one that easy? Because you can't drive a tissue paper through a brick.
Reply to
Bob La Londe
I bought a strap of leather, skived the ends, glued and made a belt. I put a fine buffing compound on it and use it to hone the edge of knives. Seems to work well.
RogerN
Reply to
RogerN
I agree that the toothiness seems to make it cut better, perhaps at some ex pense of sturdiness, but a couple (literally, 2) strokes on each side of th e edge on a steel brings the edge back, and a touchup on the belt sander co uld take perhaps a minute or less.
So, I haven't received the finer belts yet, but I'm feeling pretty confiden t in this process which takes a LOT less time than the old stones (and I ha ve pretty big collection of them).
Reply to
rangerssuck
I also have several stones of different types . I tune up the kitchen knives with one of the 3 diamond hone plates from a HF set of 3 . One resides in my shop to hone lathe bits , the 3rd floats to where needed . The only knives that get stropped to a fine edge around here are my hunting knives ...
Reply to
Terry Coombs

PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.