OT: LED lights revisited (long)

Dec 11, 2003 6 Replies
Jump to replies (6)

The recent thread on this topic got me interested in exploring these devices. I'm now working on a ringlight for my microscope using white LED's and little collimators -- but that's another story.



Check out

formatting link
The side-by-side comparison with a Mini-Maglight really got my attention. So did the pricetag!



Key elements are the housing, the LED used, the optics and the elex. I and most RCM readers can machine and knurl an aluminum housing. Anodizing is easy enough and recommended for nice smooth-running fine threads in Al. O-rings are no mystery.



I've discovered that the LED and collimating optic (molded acrylic) can be bought for $14.63 from

formatting link



That leaves the elex, but I think I can manage that OK. Might be another 5 bux.



I want mine to have adjustable brightness to match the illumination (and battery consumption) to the task at hand. I'm a bit suprised that these pricey "tactical" or "survival" lights don't provide that. it's a feature I'd definitely want if I cared about "tactical". Sometimes ya want all the light ya can get, other times a faint glimmer is sufficient and even preferable.



My Luxeon Star arrived today. It definitely outshines (pun intended) my MiniMag at WOT (350 mA) while drawing about the same current.



I'm a bit skeptical about the claim made on the abovementioned website that the reviewer could see out to 75 yards, but perhaps some of these flashlights overdrive the hell out of the LED's. That surmise is supported by the fact that he said it got noticably warm. Given nominal life of 50K hours to 70% of original brightness at rated current, I guess one could overdrive it quite a bit (with adequate heatsink) and still get acceptable lifetime. A household bulb typically lasts 1000 hours, krypton flashlight bulbs less because they run hotter. I consulted with a former colleague who happens to be the guy that invented the LED. He said his rule of thumb is that every LED has so many photons to emit, spend 'em as you will.



The real surprise was when I turned the Luxeon down some, using a lab bench supply to drive it. At 10 mA and a distance of about 30 inches it illuminates a whole page of a hardcover book brightly enough to read very comfortably even though my night vision sucks anymore. I could still read readily at 2 mA but I might not want to read for more than an hour or so that way. At 10 mA it would run at constant brightness for 178 hours on 2 alkaline AA cells. At WOT it'd only run about 5 hours. Macht nicht most of the time, since batteries are cheap, but in a lights-out sit or when 40 miles of bad road away from a store one might want a throttle: plenty of light when it's needed, plenty of battery when less light will suffice most of the time.



Elex will happen ... eventually. What I lack in lazy I make up for in slow. First rule of retirement: NOTHING IS URGENT! (Well, not yet anyway, at age 61...)



For the impatient and electronically-inclined, Maxim, Zetex and Supertex offer surfacemount (tiny) driver chips for white LEDs, They're not intended for use at 350 mA but probably could be adapted.


Snip

About the same time as the thread was running, I found and bought an LED book light at Costco. I've been using it for about an hour every night for the past two months and it's still on the first set of batteries. It hasn't even begun to dim. It'll be interesting to see how long thay last.

Right off the top of my head, I'd say it will pay for itself by the time it's depleted its first set of batteries. My old incandescent reading light went through batteries like popcorn at the movies.

I also put a Photon II light on each of our vehicles' key rings. The light they provide is nothing short of amazing. I'd recommend that everyone have an LED keyring light. You never know when you'll need it.

The Candlepower Forum is a wealth of LED information.

formatting link
...as is Flashlight Reviews

formatting link
Orrin

Snip Thanks Don for this bit of insight. My bicycle lighting system includes 2 Harbor Frieght's 15 LED 20 dollars, mag like flashlight, modified in my machine shop to use AA cells.

formatting link
I have heard that these light are pushed hard. So a year from now I can afford to replace it, maybe at 5 dollars, I paid 40 dollars for a 7 LED flashlight more than a year ago.

...>

does yours have a plastic swivel? --Loren

They are good! My old Mini Mag Light is EOL, and I was looking for a replacement. The local hardware store had a 3 LED headband light for $8.00 CDN. I snapped one up.

Steve R.

No, it is fastened to the key ring with another metal ring about 5/16" diameter.

I would have gotten Photon III because they're easier to change batteries, but their sequence of modes sounded like a PITA.

Orrin

i have cheapies, "Coast", not listed on the url you gave. they attach to the keyring with a metal 1/2" ring but from that to the light with a plastic swivel. i just wondered how these might hold up (the swivel).

thanks! --Loren

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required