OT: Strange car problem reversal--magic valves?

May 20, 2004 12 Replies

First reply

Jon Elson

If you didn't RUN the engine before a compression test, you can't expect valid results (after years of sitting). You need to get the cylinder walls oiled up well. One other trick the pros use: When preparing for a compression test, back all the plugs out a couple turns, and…

Read the full reply

Here's one I'd never seen before. For the last 9 years or so I've been stuck with my father's old '85 Subaru GL 4-door. It's been idle all this time because of bad frame rust, bad exhaust, bad brake lines, etc. About 4 years ago when I went to move the thing I found at had 15 psi compression all around. It's been on the long list to part out on eBay.



Anyway, earlier today I finished charging up a booster pack I was given. Just for kicks I hooked it up to the Subie, to see if it had enough power to crank over. You can see where this is going. First turn of the key, fires right up in a cloud of smoke, runs like a top. I mean it just purrs.



I'm guessing that the valves had stuck, and then unstuck maybe from the changing seasons and the new oil it got 4 years ago. Has anyone ever seen something like this happen? It's sure new to me. Not a million years was I expecting to see this run again. Too bad it's not economical to fix--I liked it back when it was roadable.



GTO(John)


If you didn't RUN the engine before a compression test, you can't expect valid results (after years of sitting). You need to get the cylinder walls oiled up well. One other trick the pros use: When preparing for a compression test, back all the plugs out a couple turns, and then screw them back in and reconnect the wires. Run the engine, some even gun it hard a couple of times, to blow out the carbon chips that were knocked off the end of the spark plug threads when you cracked the plugs off their seats. The carbon chips will otherwise get under the valves and cause exactly the problem you saw in the compression test.

Jon

It'd be interesting to do the compression test again to see where it is. Or better, a leak down. That'd tell you where you're losing compression.

Peter

Back when I tried to run it a few years ago, I had cranked it over for many minutes, dumped oil into the cylinders, etc. After trying off and on for about a week I gave up. I then gave it the compression test and found it had none.

GTO(John)

Maybe spider webs and rat droppings have acted as a ring sealer!

Peter

Now, that's odd. But, the advice I have heard, is cranking the engine is not enough to clear the carbon off the valves, you have to get the engine to start, at least barely.

I don't know whether it was flooded, maybe it was damp and the ignition wires were shorting out, whatever. generally, if everything else is right (mixture, ignition, valves, etc.) an engine will start and run with really BAD compression. It will have very little power under load, and may emit a HUGE cloud of smoke and foul the plugs in a minute, but it can still start with very poor compression.

Jon

Sometimes it's just a matter of the oil leaking out of the hydraulic lifters over time (depending on the engine design) so they "collapse" and don't open the valves. It can take a long time for them to pump up again when you're spinning it over trying to start it. Pre-lubing the motor by spinning the oil pump with an electric drill seems to help a lot. David

"David Courtney" wrote:(clip) Pre-lubing the motor by spinning the oil pump with an electric drill seems to help a lot. ^^^^^^^^^^^ Dave, how do you get access to the oil pump with an electric drill to spin it?

One of your neighbors has been sneaking over and fixing it up while you're not home???

Tom

That's what surprised me about this. Back four years ago I checked every major system. You could hear it fire in all four cylinders very weakly, but there just was no compression. When I cranked it yesterday it lit right up. It only has 80K and ran like new before it was parked for good a decade ago.

GTO(John)

I drove my Mazda B3000 with the 3.0 engine for 294,000 miles. When I pulled the engine, because it was getting a bit tired ( I was driving at least a 1000 miles per week) I was able to turn the engine over by hand with a socket in a 3/8 stubby ratchet. With two fingers. Never did use any oil...

Gunner

"A vote for Kerry is a de facto vote for bin Laden." Strider

For many Japanese engines, you can't. They drive the oil pump directly off the crankshaft. In other words, you have to spin the motor to make oil pressure, or use an external electric pump to prime the oiling system.

OTOH most older domestic engines drive the oil pump off the distributor shaft, so you can remove the distributor and drive the oil pump using a drill motor and a dummy distributor shaft.

Gary

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required