OT: Why Not?

Feb 17, 2005 18 Replies

First reply

Grant Erwin

George, I haven't noticed your postings before. I don't care what you do elsewhere but on rcm many of us try to raise the level of our postings somewhat above the moral level of junior high bathroom walls. Please keep your topics limited to metalworking. - GWE

Read the full reply

Referring to the Yahoo news item below:



It is only common sense that the NTSB exists and conducts investigations into transportation accidents to determine the causes so repeats can be avoided.



Simple arithmetic shows for any given year the amount of money lost is several orders of magnitude greater for aggregate business failures than for aggregate air/transportation accidents. The loss of life also appears to be much larger from business failures although not as immediate, primarily due to destructive life style changes (alcohol related, driving and spousal/child abuse deaths/injuries show a very significant increase for the employees and their families of bankrupt organizations) and loss of health benefits.



My question to the very smart people in these newsgroups is why doesn't a similar body exist for business failures in the US, with a mandate to conduct inquests on all "large" and representative samples of smaller business bankruptcies, to suggest regulatory changes to avoid reoccurrences, and to issue public reports of their findings?



Given the universal use of computerized data links such as the Internet for financial transactions and business communications, it should not be that difficult/expensive to create a "black box recorder" for corporations above a certain size, and require that all transactions/communications go through the 'black box' for data retrieval in the case of an 'accident.'



We expect our airline pilots and commercial drivers to submit to periodic physical and mental examinations to verify their fitness for these responsible positions, and random checks are made for drug/alcohol abuse. Should the same be required for officers and board members of our major corporations?



GmcD



============================== Cause of Fatal Colo. Jet Crash Sought By ROBERT WELLER, Associated Press Writer PUEBLO, Colo. - Federal investigators said the pilots of a Circuit City corporate jet were battling poor weather just before the plane crashed a few miles from an airport, killing all eight on board.



The FAA planned a safety meeting for Friday in Washington, D.C.,



"It's a meeting to talk about industry best practices," she said.



The NTSB is still working to determine the cause of a Nov. 28 crash of a twin-engine CL-601 Challenger ==================================


Now wait a minute, lets not be hasty, I think he's on to something. Since the governments of the world in the last century were responsible for more loss of life and property (especially to their own citizens) than all the above combined who better to control these things than an organization that specializes in and understands loss of life and property. For department of agriculture I would nominate mao or stallen two government standouts in the field of collective agriculture.

There are good reasons a trucker needs to pass a physica but a supreme court justice does not.

Rex B wrote:

F. George McDuffee wrote in news: snipped-for-privacy@4ax.com:

I'd have to agree with what Rex B wrote, but I'd like to add two points as well. First, much of your future savings you would expect to achieve by "learning from past mistakes" would be mitigated by the cost of the bureaucracy needed to control such a process. Once we let big government in to the decision-making process...costs will skyrocket. Second, where would the authority for such governmental power come from? I know, I know...why should congress start worrying about the Constitution at this point? There are few politicians who even bother to ask themselves if what they are voting on is constitutional, before they try to decide if it is right or wrong. One of the few I've found that breaks the mold is Congressman Ron Paul from Texas.

formatting link

It's so hard to try and apply a constitutional litmus test to new legislation because the populace is already so used to the government stepping-in and getting involved in just about all aspects of life. That may be one reason why suggestions such as the following are always creeping into our lives:

AND

To conclude, I don't think the principle behind such an idea is bad...in essence, you're trying to make the world a better place...but in order to keep our government's powers in check (and hopefully avoid ANOTHER revolution, like the one that formed this country) we need to hold them to their promise to be guided and restrained by our Constitution.

George,

It's a very small step from what you propose, to Orwell's "1984"

Mark

You're too late, George. The government's been doing exactly what you suggest. Been doing it for decades, as a matter of fact.

The folks in Washington kept close watch on the US railroad industry, performed detailed post-mortems on roads that got into trouble, and even helped a few of the more worthy ones, after they figured out what had gone wrong. Same with airlines, which are now as healthy, as efficient, and as financially sound as government oversight and assistance can make them. Just ask all the happy customers and secure employees at Eastern, or Pan Am, or TWA.

And, of course, there was plenty of thought and care given to the nation's savings and loan companies, and to the rules and regulations necessary to keep them from hurting people.

Other important industries which have been the subject of government scrutiny and care have been the energy industry and the communications business; both of which are vital to not only the quality of life for vast numbers of individuals; but also for the economy as a whole, and for national security, too. Enron and Adelphia are just two of the many stellar names that our regulators can include on their resume's.

At present, there's a great deal of discussion and debate in Washinton about other areas where the government might protect us. Look for results that are AT LEAST as good as we've seen in the past, just as soon as the government starts getting serious about health care reform, the social security system, and the prescription drug business.

Personally, I have my own plan: I'm spending every extra penny I can find on prescription drugs, which I plan to store in a giant, climate-controlled vault. When prices and supplies are eventually controlled by the government, my stock of drugs will appreciate at least

10-fold in value. Maybe more. And when nobody can find or see a doctor, I'll at least be able to try self-medication. That's not a good option, really; but it'll be better than what most other people will have. And, of course, when I retire, I'll have assets more valuable than gold, to fund my golden years.

Yes, I know you think I'm exaggerating the danger. I assume you got your flu shot, right?

KG

All failures caused by DEREGULATION, not excessive regulation!

lol bs the left likes to claim deregulation is the cause of certain business failures, . they do this by carefully staging deregulations on businesses just as they are about to fail, this then allows them to swoop in and re overregulate if not take out right control of said business. the railroad company is a good example.. amtrack is not privately owned... CA's power crisis is a good example.. before the rolling black outs, grey(out) davis deregulated the power companies.. but it was too little too late.. so rolling blackouts commenced, and grey davis and the rest of the whack job lefties claimed deregulation was the cause,

So that's why Enron and its cohorts are currently (no pun intended, but since it's laying there...) doing a frantic dance trying to cover up/suppress the evidence of their criminal conspiracy aimed at driving the price of power sky high by deliberately creating "shortages" that didn't actually exist except on paper?

The energy companies were deregulated prior to Davis taking office.

communications

not totally, but the point is still the same.. they deregulate the power industry, after decades of over regulation.. it ends up being too little too late,, power prices spike, you get black outs, and they blame deregulation., when really it's just the collapse caused by over regulation..... come on.. this is CA one of the largest economic forces in the nation, and they are having black outs because they can't produce enough power??,. if a company was allowed to make a reasonable profit building and running a power plant, they *never* would have had this problem.. there's absolutely no excuse for it, but nooo these stupid stupid lefties want to sit there and blame deregulation., greedy power companies etc.. same old crap, even thou they were millions (billions??) in debt..

**** shu

That's not even close to the truth. Railroads were political animals almost from the day that steam locomotives were invented. Land grants, rights of way, exclusivity in selected territories, "controlled competition" in others, mail contracts, and more, were all granted or sold on the basis of political pull and outright corruption. The few truly private railroads that once existed in this country never had a chance. And when the Eisenhower administration committed itself to the contruction of an interstate highway system, and to the rapid development of high-volume civilian air-travel, then the railroads were left to die. They never, EVER existed in a free state, and couldn't survive when their "regulators" moved on to greener pastures.

What we call railroads today, like Amtrak, aren't businesses at all; but only government subsidies for a relatively small population of users.

Airlines aren't "deregulated". That's just a lie that was told often enough that people started to believe it. What actually happened was that a small part of the total regulatory picture was restructured, and airlines became free to buy and sell each other like kids playing Monopoly, and to set prices by whim. That was it. No airline in the US operates a single flight, or consumes a single square foot of space at a single airport, without approval from the FAA, the NTSB, and more. And, as the original post suggested, the govenment DID perform extensive post-mortem examinations of Eastern, Pan Am, TWA, etc., and DID decide to use loans, grants, "controlled competition", and other destructive measures, to prop up the airlines that haven't died, and to make sure that they REMAIN in the political arena for our policy makers to play with. The current state of the airline industry - barnkrupt, and just barely able to move passengers and baggage - is the necessary, inescapable result of the government's policies.

(An intersting counterpoint is the non-passenger segment of the airline business. Companies like UPS, FedEx, and DHL really DO operate with a completely different, and much less burdensome. set of rules. Those companies ARE allowed to operate on market forces rather than just regulatory mandates. As a result, I can get 150 lbs of freight to anywhere in the world - faster, cheaper, and MUCH more reliably - than I can move 150 lbs of me to an airport just a few hundred miles away.)

Enron and Adelphia were both cases where the government had regulations and rules in place, and where the most clever, insidious, and harmful crimes were NOT the manipulation of products, inventory, or investment dollars; but the extent to which the crooks manipulated incompetent or dishonest REGULATORS, in order to fool their customers and stockholders. You may recall that there was a rather large accounting firm, licensed to audit the businesses, which took much of the blame for the catastrophies. And the SEC could have, should have, known what was happening YEARS before it hit the fan, if regulation actually worked.

And the savings and loan debacle? There hasn't been a bank (or anything that looks or smells like a bank) in this country in 70 years that operated for an instant without an entire arm of the federal government watching its every move. The reason things went to hell in that business is NOT because they were deregulated; but because the regulators CAN'T offer the protection they promise. What they actually do is provide a false sense of security, which invites comsumers and investors to let down their guards and live without reasonable, common sense self-protection strategies. Then things go to hell. Always. Every single time.

And we're currently watching the systematic, wholesale destruction of our health care industry - by exactly the same methods. 20 years from now, going to doctor will be nearly impossible. And if you DO see a doctor, the first thing on his/her mind will be how to keep the lawyers and regulators happy. And the very LAST priority will be treating patients. That's almost the case already; but it'll get much, MUCH worse in years to come. Same with drug companies, health insurance providers, and even the local pharmacy.

Regulations, 99.9% of the time, are nothing more than a facade of false safety, offered by liars who want to get elected, but who either don't understand that they CAN'T keep their promises, or don't care that they can't, as long as they get our votes.

KG

Obviously nothing has been totally deregulated. Part of the reason that the regulators can't offer the protection that they promise is the gutting of the SEC and other agencies- and the fact that the best lawyers, etc., are on the other side.

Ayup

Pete Wilson ring any bells?

formatting link
Restructuring of California's Electric Utility Industry Information From the California Energy Commission

Beginning March 31, 1998, many of California's electricity consumers were allowed to make choices when they purchased their electricity. The decades-old structure of area-specific monopolies for electricity was changed under what is called "restructuring" or deregulation. Begun by the California Public Utilities Commission in

1992, the course electricity deregulation took was directed by legislation, mainly Assembly Bill 1890 and Senate Bill 90.

Because of flaws in the deregulation process, the California Public Utilities Commission suspended direct access in September 2001. Other problems, too numerous to explain here, also occurred. Many periodicals and books have examined and analyzed what went wrong with the state deregulation efforts. We'd recommend investigating those books and magazines at your local public or school library.

Under restructuring, the California Energy Commission was directed by the Legislature to deal with restructuring's impacts on renewable energy; energy research, development and demonstration (RD&D) programs; create a retail electricity disclosure program; and hold proceedings focussing on information access. Four Web Sites have been created by the Energy Commission to focus on these areas.

Gunner

Rule #35 "That which does not kill you, has made a huge tactical error"

================== I thought the California power company deregulation was payback by the pols that lost their jobs because of voter mandated term limits. A little somthing to remember them by ....

GmcD

===================== Companies that demand special treatment on the one hand such as tax breaks, limitations on liability, tariffs, and public guarantees on their debt obligations [e.g. PBGC] not available to the average citizens and the smaller companies should expect to have special responsibilities.

Most likely the special requirements I suggested would not be cost effective if applied across the board, but would be highly cost effective when applied to the Fortune 500/1000 or the Russell 2000 corporations. There is a qualitative as well as a quantitative difference between these organizations and everyone/everything else in the US economy. For one thing the gross sales of just one of these corporations is larger than the combined GDP of many of the nations with UN representation.

A few of the differences:

(1) No matter how much money you have, you are not allowed to operate an aircraft unless you possess a license indicating minimum competency for the type of aircraft you intend to fly. [Check the (lack of) qualifications of most of the executives who were running the large companies that just crashed and burned.]

(2) 'Incidents' are investigated as a matter of routine, not just when the public wants someone's head on a pike to carry down the street. [I.e. Martha Stewart]

(3) When a plane goes down, accident investigation specialists and as required a large verity of independent specialists/experts, are involved, not adversarial lawyers, 'spin-doctors,' and airtime seeking gasbag politicians.

(4) The 'black box' is generally recovered which shows exactly what the plane was doing prior to impact. [Re document shredding at Enron/Arthur Anderson]

(5) Specific topical recommendations generally result. [Sarbanes-Oxley appears to be a step forward in that it generally eliminates the CEO 'Nuremberg' defense of 'I didn't know.']

(6) Public reports of the independent findings are made widely and easily available.

(7) Accident prone, careless, incompetent, addicted, and simply 'unlucky' pilots, AF&E mechanics and other critical personnel for the most part are 'weeded out' before they cause a catastrophe.

This does not seem to be the case with most (all?) of the recent large business/financial debacles.

F------ George,

When you crash your SUV (regulated) while jabbering on a cell phone (regulated) and kill an innocent emigrant (unregulated) who is driving a p.o.s. junker (unregulated), blame it all on Judge Greene. You do remember JudgeGreene, don't you?

Bob Swinney

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required