I like to try to mention things that are good. Not just whine about things that aren't, but as I pointed out before it seems like the moment I praise something it goes south.
I've used a lot of welding gloves over the years. The biggest issue is my fault of course. I cook off the fingers. By the time I realize my hand is getting hot the fingers are cooked into hard shrunken caricatures of their former selves. Most welding gloves are also stiff, and the softer "TIG" gloves cook off easier than other welding gloves.
I've been using a pair of Vulcan Defender (Harbor Freight) welding gloves for the last year or a little better, and I've been doing more welding in the last couple years than I have in the past. Just yesterday I was thinking, "The gloves still haven't cooked of, and they are much more flexible (for a welding glove) than others I have used. While they aren't the perfect welding glove they might be the best one I have used." I was in the process of taking them off to walk inside and post about them here on this very newsgroup, when the lining of the right glove came out with my hand.
No, its not quite as comical as the mental image that might conjure up for you. The liner fingers came out of the leather fingers and part way up the cuff of the glove. I wasn't able to just push my fingers back into to get it situated either. I had to pull the liner most of the rest of the way out of the glove, and one finger at a time poke a finger into the liner to straighten it out. Then I was able to one at a time fit my fingers into the liner and push the liner back into the glove. The glove is saved, but its going to be a pain in the wazoo to use from now one. I'll have to grab the finger tip of each finger and pinch the liner in place as I extract my hand every single time I use it from now on.
Yes Jim, You Only Have To Think About It