There's a tool in Wildfire made especially for this task of converting 2D views
3D solid geometry called AutobuildZ. So, since I've never used it, I guess I'd
have to ask my own question: anyone used it? opinions? Worth the trouble of
My overall assessment after evaluating AutobuildZ is that the user would be
better off to create their models from scratch. I found that the flow of
feature creation actually goes faster by not having to toggle back and forth
2-D drawing window and a part file window just to add features. Also, there
were a few times where the 'depth' definition of features didn't behave
properly. Seemed pretty buggy to me at times.
In summary, I wouldn't waste my time learning AutobuildZ. Obviously this is
just my own personal opinion on the topic, so you can take it for what it's
worth. But I really and truly wasn't very impressed with the AutobuildZ
modeling methodology. Yes, a fully parametric model can be created this way.
But again, I think the user would be disappointed.
You suppose it would depend on whether they were coming from the 2D or 3D world?
whether they were Pro users looking for a shortcut to getting AutoCAD drawings
into models? or ACAD users, new to Pro and having the fewest expectations,
to get their 2D data into a 3D format with minimal trouble? I suspect the latter
audience would be the least disappointed, from what you are saying, Ron. Pro
would probably expect something more automated, something that produced some 3D
sceanarios from 2D geometry and let users cycle through them ~ a good bit more
automation than seems in evidence.
Absolutely. I think that someone with very little Pro/E experience would
appreciate AutobuildZ much more than a longtime Pro/E user.
You hit the nail right on the head with your assessment David. People that
are relatively new to the 3-D MCAD world may think that the AutobuildZ
modeling methodology for generating a Pro/E model is somewhat impressive. I
do believe that most experienced Pro/E users would be like..."This is pretty
cumbersome. I think I'll just create my model from scratch. It's gotta be
faster than this!"
Thank you for your help. I think I'm going to follow Ron M's
suggestions and model the parts from scratch.
Because I'm new to Pro/E, I think I need the experience to model and
draw parts from the beginning.
Thanks again! Happy Fourth....
On Wed, 21 Jun 2006 08:24:20 -0700, email@example.com wrote:
Polytechforum.com is a website by engineers for engineers. It is not affiliated with any of manufacturers or vendors discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.