This is probably a very basic question, but it is troubling me.
In my robot's design, I have a couple of daughterboards running PICs (or maybe other uC's). I want to design a circuit for supplying power to the daugherboards.
The main power source is a battery pack that supplies 12V. What I'm trying to decide is whether I design one extra daughterboard for voltage regulation or if I include voltage regulation in each one of the daughterboards. Here's what I see as advantages and disadvantes of each method, please critique.
One VReg ======== Advantages:
- savings in real estate
- savings in power consumption Disadvantages:
- If I install a diode or a bridge rectifier on the daughterboard, I won't have 5V for the electronics because of the v.drop of the diodes
- If one of the daughterboards needs 3.3V instead of 5V, I will need a vreg on the daughterboard anyway
Distributed VRegs ================= Advantages:
- Each board is encapsulated, which means I can connect any voltage (in between vreg specified min and max) that it will work
- I can select a specific vreg for each board according to its characteristics (current and voltage needs)
- I may choose a vreg with overvoltage and overcurrent features
- I can implement the reverse polarity diode before the vreg, therefore the diode voltage drop won't affect the voltage available for the load Disadvantages
- real estate
- power consumption
(cost is not really a problem... this is not going to production)
Cheers
Padu