SW2004 - First Impression

Sep 25, 2003 4 Replies

Hi All,



I have just had the opportunity to use SolidWorks 2004 SP0.0 as downloaded from the SW website on a production job. Actually a customer specifically requested it. I have been using SolidWorks since version 96+ but have not had the chance to look at 04 yet. Nothing like jumping right into the frying pan.



I am designing a four cavity family injection mould with two slides per cavity and a contoured parting line.



Off the bat, I was a little confused by changes to some menu structure. Oh well, menus are menus and this will just take a little getting used to.



Don't like some of the new automation features. Specifically I don't like the way it automatically tries to insert the last open object into a new assembly. 95% of the time it is not what I want to do. Though I do like the automatic preview. I am also not terribly fond of the new assembly mating. when you only want to assign one mate you have to click twice to OK it and if you cancel out half way through assigning multiple mates, you lose the ones you had assigned already. I know I have to learn how to use the new functions, but I lost a few mates and features when I was in a rush to get an assembly done. I also do not like the office assistant style help key. Some of this stuff I am sure I just have to get used to. I'm sure I'll find a way to adjust preferences to work the way I want them to.



The system has been crashing more often than I'd like. I'm averaging twice per day, taking me to desktop. I save often. I'm confident they'll sort out the bugs in the first service pack.



I also had a problem with multi-sheet drawings. When inserting a second page the software was unable to load the sheet format. When that drawing was opened a second time (with a blank second page), it caused SolidWorks to crash to desktop. This may just be a corruption with my download/installation, but I would like to hear if other users have the same problems.



I'll leave on a positive note. The program does seem to run faster than 03 on my computer (Athlon2700, 1GbRAM, Quadro4-750XGL-128Mb). I really like the new surfacing and mold tools commands. It really helped generate the complex parting line on my tool. I am also excited by the new table features like the hole chart and revision block. I have wanted something like this for quite some time. The change from 2003 to 2004 is much more significant than the change from



2001+ to 2003. With some of this new functionality, I am all the more anxious that they fix the little bugs.

Cheers,



Rob Lemmen KORVER ENGINEERING Ltd.


Yeah, I kind of like the new flyout menu buttons but I have a problem with them. If you dock them on the right or left side of the screen, they take up as much space as TWO rows of command buttons (if they were placed side by each :^)) For me this defeats the purpose of trying to unlcutter the workspace. A big gray area to me is even worse than nothing at all.

On the other hand, if you place them above or below your workspace, they can really save realestate!

Thankfully, you can modify everything to look almost exactly like

2003 if you want.

Mike Wilson

This may help...

*) Hold down the "Alt" key *) Select the first face, edge, vertex etc. you wish to mate *) Drag the part to the mating face, edge, vertex etc. *) Observe the mouse pointer icon status *) Release mouse *) Select the checkbox

This is a new fancy way of doing a SmartMate. If you want to change alignment, you can let go of the Alt key and hit Tab.

SmartMate doesn't work for all occasions, but it's definitely handy!

Mike Wilson

I am also experiencing the same multi-sheet drawing problem. I even tried to re-save my sheet formats under '04 but that didn't work either -- just a crash to the desktop. In addition, I am also having problems with drawing templates. I made some subtle changes to some that I was using under 2003, then re-saved them. Now when I try to create a new drawing using these templates SW2004 bombs giving me the 'ole "Unexpected file type" error...

I am hoping that these problems are simply related to the web download version of SW2004 SP0.0 and not an actual problem with the CD versions. I know there are other "known" issues with the Web version of SP0.0 such as opening AutoCAD drawings and such. My VAR says you have to make sure to completely clean out the Registry BEFORE you install SP0.0 - especially if you had PR 1 or 2 loaded! I did however notice that on the SWX website they have now posted a simple (apparently) little program to do this for you in the subscription support section, under downloads... Well enough of this rant...

My favorite enhancement has been the Hole Chart. Today I found that it seems to be having trouble with a dim. of exactly.1.0 , it always puts a 0.0 instead. If I move the hole to either 1.0001 or .9999 the chart updates to the correct dim. Hope I can find out what is wrong because I really like this feature.

Danny Medlin Monroe Custom Molds

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required