OT - Need to make thin ice quickly

Dec 31, 2004 21 Replies
Jump to replies (21)

Hi all,



I realize this is way off topic, but I'm hoping that the collective wisdom here might stray into the required area of expertise...



I need to create a thin sheet of ice (.0125"-ish) on a plywood ramp approximately 12" wide and 60" long, and I need to do it quickly; no longer than 10 minutes. I can't build anything substantial into the ramp (IOW, no refrigeration coils under the ramp), but anything else might be feasible. Dry ice and water? I've heard some fire extinguishers could be used to freeze water? Any suggestions?



Peter


Do a Google search on supercooled water. Under the right conditions water can be cooled to below freezing temperature withoutt freezing. I don't know if you could get transferred from the container to the plywood without it freezing en route, but it might be worth a try.

Mind telling us why? It might help stimulate the imagination.

Does the ramp have to be plywood? Does it have to be in place beforehand, or could it live in a freezer? What will the ambient temp be? What's the budget? Does the ice actually have to be a solid sheet, or would packed snow be okay? Does the ice have to be that thin or could it be thicker? How long does the ice have to last? How many times does it have to work?

It's for a contest that involves rolling/sliding model vehicles down the ramp and I'm looking for "the unfair advantage".

Yep. It's already built. As I think about it, it could conceivably have some sort of "insert" that had the ice on it and was just placed on the ramp.

We don't have a freezer big enough. Besides, I want to be able to do this quickly, in situ so that we are the only people to use this technique.

60-ish

$100.... conceivably more for something truly brilliant.

Solid sheet would be slipperiest. Packed snow won't give the advantage I'm looking for.

It could be as thick as .75".

10 minutes.

Once or maybe twice.

I'm thinking liquid nitrogen...?

I didn't get the original post, but another google search would be for "Hilsch vortex tube" which can be made from plumbing fittings, and outputs supercooled AIR. Maybe shooting into a temporary insulated box over the ramp, which contains a water mist spray?

Ken Grunke

You need a good heat transfer and wood isn't the greatest. First thing that would come to my mind would be a sheet metal boxed section that would lay on the ramp with dry ice and maybe isopropol alcohol inside...

Is ice the only thing you can squeeze under the rules with?

Could you use a sheet of glass with a little water sprayed on it?

Happy New Year,

Jeff

I think I would consider instead laminating a sheet of teflon or uhmw onto the board.

formatting link

As I understand it, you don't ice - you just want low friction. In that case, why not use liquid nitrogen/dry ice to power a sort of hovercraft effect ...

Posted Via Nuthinbutnews.Com Premium Usenet Newsgroup Services

---------------------------------------------------------- ** SPEED ** RETENTION ** COMPLETION ** ANONYMITY **

----------------------------------------------------------

formatting link

What are you trying to accomplish by doing this? Some kind of FX?

Does it need to be visible as it happens? and does it matter if it *IS* visible as it happens? Even if it doesn't need to be visible? IE, is this video - don't care, since we can cut as needed, or are we live-action in front of an audience that isn't supposed to see the transformation from not-iced to iced take place?) If no all of the above questions, simple:

60 inches... Hmm... 5 feet by a foot. One man can carry easily.

Have two ramp surfaces. One bare, one pre-iced. (or perhaps one with one side iced, the other not) Stow the iced one in a freezer (Prolly have to be chest type) Switch as needed while the ramp isn't being used/is out of the shot.

Another option that MIGHT work - I've never tried it, but it's a thought- Liquid nitrogen - Douse the ramp with it, give it a few moments to chill, dump more LN2 over it, then sluice water down it. Repeat to desired thickness of ice. One iteration may be plenty for what you're asking about doing.

How about spraying it with water and then pouring liquid nitrogen over it? I don't think that liquid N2 is all that expensive.

Leon

Hovercraft.

Do you have to have directional control?

What about lining the bottom of the VEHICLE with dry ice? Done right the vehicle floats on a cloud of CO2.

Make a little lip around the plywood ramp and spray it with a mist sprayer. Blast this with compressed CO2 from an extinguisher or a larger tank until it frosts over and then spritz it again with the water and repeat several times until the ice builds up in a layer.

You might want to experiment with coating the board before spraying the water or spraying the wet board first, not sure what would be quicker.

Also you want to have ice cold water inside the sprayer. You might also salt the wet board or experiment with a brine solution as your base layer with fresh water ice as a topping. My thought here is the brine ice will maintain a lower temperature and the subsequent layers will melt slower. I might have the physics wrong here but experimentation should help.

Even better... one sprayer with hot water, and one with cold, so that he can make a definitive report to the readers of the "freezing pipes" thread. :-)

Wayne

I have doubts that this will work on the typical roughness of plywood. I think it will stick rather than slide freely. How about making the bottom of the object flat, drilling a hole in the center, and supplying compessed air form a tiny internal tank? An air bearing will likely work a LOT better, and the friction will be as close to zero as you're going to get.

Jon

Mixing liquid nitrogen and water is VERY dangerous, as the nitrogen will boil explosively!

Cooling an object with liq N2 and then spraying water on it is at least safe, but will result in some pretty rough ice. I suspect you want some smooth ice.

Jon

Thank you all for your suggestions. After considering the possibilities, and the time in which I had to what I wanted, and after experimenting a bit with some dry ice, I decided to cop out and use some heavy duty polyethylene sheet. Next year I'll be more prepared and have a little more time.

Thanks,

Peter

I rather liked the air bottle "hovercraft" idea. Ive seen folks use

3/8" plate and an airhose to move very large machinery like magic.

Gunner

"War is an ugly thing, but not the ugliest of things. The decayed and degraded state of moral and patriotic feeling which thinks that nothing is worth war is much worse. The person who has nothing for which he is willing to fight, nothing which is more important than his own personal safety, is a miserable creature and has no chance of being free unless made and kept so by the exertions of better men than himself."

- John Stewart Mill

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required