I've joined this group with the hope it can become quite useful in my current job. I'm a mechanical engineer who at times will have to do hands-on stuff that no one else here wants to do. My current task is trying to figure out a swaging process using an old, outdated rotary swager made by a company years ago by the name of Hampden. We just want to do up various tapers on .120" OD SS tubing (304), 11 ga., but trying different wall thickness too (.006 and .010). My questions thus far are does anyone here have experience with this type of process? What are the recommended tool steels to use for the small swaging dies? What surface treatment is needed for swaging dies? And what type of lubrication is recommended for the swaging of SS tubing?
At the present time, I am using heat treated O-1 tool steel for the dies, with mixed results... a lot of galling problems. I've tried regular motor oil, Lucas oil treatment, and lithium grease for lubrication. Any advice on this would be greatly appreciated. Or if you can just point me in the right direction on where to find such info? Thanks in advance!
Didn't find your answer? Ask the community — no account required.
F
F. George McDuffee
=============== Welcome to RMC -- any advice you get here will be worth at least twice what you pay for it.....
Your success will depend a *GREAT* deal on the exact SS alloy you use. SS is infamous for work-hardening, and if you chose the wrong alloy it will be like trying to swage glass after (or even half-way during) the first pass.
Consistent, uniform annealed/normalized tubing will be critical to any production process, so work closely with a reputable vendor, and establish early on that this is an "engineering approved supplier" component (and squash the first purchasing agent like a bug that gets a "great" deal on the tubing!) some possible suppliers:
formatting link
I don't know what sort of tolerances you are trying to hold on the dies, or if you are doing a final grind after heat-treat, but you may want to consider A1 rather than O1 with a vacuum/inert heat-treat. This will reduce dimensional and surface chemical changes. Carbo-nitride is another option to get a better wear surface.
You may want to consider the PVD [physical vapor deposition] coating such as TiN or the newer, more exotic ones. These provide a very hard and smooth surface, and resist metal "pick up."
As far as your lubrication question -- first be sure that you actually have galling and not some sort of mechanical surface spalling, possibly due to work hardening. If you are having mechanical bonding [classical galling] lard oil or caster oil can provide extreme pressure lubrication but can be difficult to remove from the finished product. Castrol makes a product called Moly-D that I have had good luck with. 10.37$US a pint at Enco see:
formatting link
TiN coatings will provide some chemical bonding protection if this is the problem.
Unless your shop is exceptional [unique?] every possible control and adjustment will be changed by the operators, foremen, and possibly the sweepers. I strongly suggest that when you design the production units, these have *NO* operator accessible settings/adjustments, and that all processing changes, and swaging dies must come through engineering.
for what the competition is doing see:
formatting link
depending on the potential volume, you may want to consider OP [outside processing]
If you look at history you'll find that no state has been so plagued by its rulers as when power has fallen into the hands of some dabbler in philosophy or literary addict.
Rather than trying to reinvent the technology, maybe the best answer is to let a pro do it.
formatting link
Randy
N
Ned Simmons
I've got three references here that all give W1 as the first choice for rotary swaging dies, citing the benefits of a hard wear resisistant skin and soft core. For larger dies where higher toughness is required, lower carbon water-hardening steels, shock resisting (S series), and L6 are mentioned.
George's recommendation of a wear resisting treatment squares with the hard surface/tough core requirement, especially in light of the galling you're experiencing. I'd add TiAlN and TiCN to the list of candidate surface treatements.
Ned Simmons
R
Roger Andersson
Vancron 40
Vancron 40 is a nitrided powder metallurgical tool steel offering an excellent combination of galling resistance and adhesive wear resistance. Vancron 40 is ideal for severe production conditions and / or long run production in applications where surface coated tool steel is needed in order to solve the above tooling problems.
Due to the powder manufacturing route used, Vancron 40 has a superior machinability compared to similar conventionally produced grades. The dimension stability during heat treatment is good, and in opposite to other conventionally produced high alloyed steels, also predictable. However, the big advantage with Vancron 40 is that it is designed to be used without surface coating. This is possible due to high amounts of vanadium rich nitrides in the matrix.
Benefits:
a.. Longer tool life, improved overall economy and less maintenance and tool failure disturbances due to the excellent galling / adhesive wear properties
b.. Longer production runs and more parts produced due to the unique low friction surface properties
c.. Vancron 40 is designed to replace surface coated tool steel, when surface coating is used to reduce galling and adhesive wear.
d.. The excellent galling / adhesive wear properties guarantees high and uniform quality from the first to the last part produced
I see also that they have sales offices in USA.
U.S.A. Head Office & Warehouse: BOHLER-UDDEHOLM CORPORATION
Cheers Roger Andersson "Norsemanu" skrev i meddelandet news: snipped-for-privacy@b28g2000cwb.googlegroups.com...
begin 666 arrow_link_internal.gif M1TE&.#EA!@`)`*(``/___[_*SX"6H$%B< (N0?___P```````"'Y! 44``4` E+ `````&``D```,7&%)
S
Steve Walker
I used to use a rotary swager to resize the I.D. of prebought copper (.250 O.D., .035 I.D.) to get different sizes for wire welding tips. We used baby powder, lots of it. Sweep it up & use it again. Keep the floor clean before swaging so's you don't pick up any big particles.
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required
Report Content
You are reporting this content to the moderators. They will look at it
ASAP.