USB to serial converter working ? and USB hubs attached to usb-serial converter

Hello,
I have seen some references in the newgroups where people have shelled
out some money for USB to rs-232 adapters/converters in order for their
serial sensors (gps, other...) to be connected to the newly set of
laptops that have no longer serial nor parallel outputs. Can any of you
share his/her experience with a particularly bad piece of hardware and
the type of the sensors it did not work with ?
My own interest is to connect not one sensor, but two using the serial
output (i.e. I have two sensors needing rs-232 output) I also have only
1 usb connection on that lapttop and think that on top of using a 2
rs-232/usb adapter, I will probably plug it to a usb hub because I need
to have access to other usb sensors (web cams). If you also have an
insight on the type of hub that work for this particular type of
configuration, I will not mind for any insight (some of the hubs I
bought before had problems even when they were powered!).
Thanks in advance,
Jake.
Reply to
Newbie
Loading thread data ...
If you did a search on the subject, it will take you several days to read all that had been posted!
Newbie wrote:
shelled
serial
Reply to
pcmobile99
If you did a search on the subject, it will take you several days to read all that had been posted over the years!
Newbie wrote:
shelled
serial
Reply to
pcmobile99
Thanks,
I guess I am really interested on the most recent experiences as I would expect the bad piece of hardware to have been weeded out from the list of offerings.
Jake.
Reply to
Newbie
I have used a number of serial to USB converters that ranged from generic unbranded ones to ones sold by Palm and Belkin. The Palm one has not worked reliably with anything but Palm devices. The Belkin has been very stable and I have not found a serial device (mostly with GPS receivers on PDAs) that I could not get to work with it.
One warning, don't plug in any serial/USB converter until you read the setup instructions. Generally, you are required to run the driver install before you plug the converter in and that seems to contribute to success in setting it up and getting it working. With the driver installed, the converter should plug and play the first time it is plugged in and found listed in the Port (COM & LPT) listing.
To see the range of types of and prices for serial to USB converters, browse them in an eBay search. You can see the variety without buying anything.
I've not used any USB hubs yet, but I would proceed carefully on how much load I put on a USB port. I would probably look for a hub that had a jack for a external 5V power source to let me take the load off of the USB bus when connecting many devices or a single device with a heavy draw. The USB 1.1 and USB 2.0 protocols limit bus supplied power to 2.5 Watts (0.5A @ +5V) per port so when you use a hub that 0.5A limit would have to cover all the devices on the hub. That is not much power if you add things like printers or external drives.
Jack
Reply to
Jack Erbes
Jake, have a good read through the customer feedback on this one. Near the bottom of the page.
formatting link
Cheers Don...
Reply to
Don McKenzie
Go to ebay and get a used Edgeport USB-to-serial converter for ~$30 (4 or 8 port). Lot of good reviews on this product. You can also get the single port adapters. The top one below can be had on ebay for $10 and works well for my uses. The bottom one below with the screwed up square looking DB9 connector (with attach screws!) is pretty much junk (I can't get to put out a signal on the tx pin).
formatting link
Reply to
Si Ballenger
I picked up a couple of USB-Serial converters today for $15, they worked fine with no problems to several different devices. The drivers needed to be installed but other than that just plug and play. I have also used a USB to 4 serial port device without any problems. All of these were plugged into a USB hub.
You may also want to consider a USB-Bluetooth device and then some Serial-Bluetooth devices. There may be power issues for your sensors depending on what they are, the setup is more complex and the hardware more expensive but there is something to be said for wireless connections.
Newbie wrote:
Reply to
Andy
Check out this thread in sci.electronics.misc
formatting link
Reply to
Mark Haase
I had real difficulties with MCT's USB-Serial cable. The problem was, the cable would see GPS data coming in and think the GPS was a serial mouse.
Usually, mouse detection is done by Windows, and there are several ways to defeat it. With this cable, internal firmware did the mouse detection. Using a USB sniffer, I could see the cable identified itself with a different ID when the GPS was attached. Everytime I powered up, I had to unplug the cable, unplug the GPS, plug in the cable, then plug in the GPS. A real pain.
I tried to contact MCT, but never got a response.
In retropect, I should have tried playing with the RS-232 control lines. It might be, if I tied the status lines high (or low, or to DSR), the firmware might not get confused. Just a hunch. I ran out of patience.
Outcome? The cable went into the trash and my Garmin GPS16 is idle. I switched to GPS18s with USB.
- John
(Note: the GPS 18 Usb is not compatible with many software packages.)
Newbie wrote:
shelled
Reply to
John
Are you sure you only have one usb port on the notebook??
Anway, I use a keyspan to drive my gps, program scanners, etc. I had to return a Belkin and IOGear.
I suppose you could get a multiport keyspan and avoid the hub.
formatting link
Keyspan devices have a few modes. I had to run mine in a hardware compatible mode or something like that, where it generated IRQs, but this was to program a scanner. The stock mode worked fine on the gps. I'm a bit fuzzy on this because I set it up a few years ago and haven't had any problems with the set up since, so it is not fresh in my mind.
Reply to
miso
Mark:
Do you have a title for this thread, I am reading this thread with google groups betas and the whole address is cut in half.
Thanks,
Jake.
Mark Haase wrote:
formatting link
read/7f83a4339536fa20/a5c54523792e67ce#a5c54523792e67ce
Reply to
Newbie
Cut and paste the two parts into the address bar in your browser.
Alternatively use this
formatting link
Go to
formatting link
to see how to make long-winded URLs USENET-friendly.
Reply to
Phil Cook
Cut and paste the two parts into the address bar in your browser.
Alternatively use this
formatting link
Go to
formatting link
to see how to make long-winded URLs USENET-friendly.
Reply to
Phil Cook
Have a look at the feedback down the bottom of:
formatting link
this works with the earlier Garmin's.
Don...
Reply to
Don McKenzie
Go to ebay and get a used Edgeport USB-to-serial converter for ~$30 (4 or 8 port). Lot of good reviews on this product. You can also get the single port adapters. The top one below can be had on ebay for $10 and works well for my uses. The bottom one below with the screwed up square looking DB9 connector (with attach screws!) is pretty much junk (I can't get to put out a signal on the tx pin).
formatting link
Reply to
Si Ballenger

PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.