I was run out of a shopping mall in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania some years ago for taking pictures. I was in Harrisburg on vacation visiting family and my Aunt wanted to go shopping there and I volunteered to be chauffeur. I just wanted a couple of pictures of this mall for vacation remembrances and here comes this guy waving his arms and shouting "You can't take pictures in here". I tried to explain but he didn't speak english, only lawyer. When ever I visited in later years I avoided the place like the morgue.
Bill Shuey
Didn't find your answer? Ask the community — no account required.
C
Captain Haddock
Ahh Bill, but were you actually in the Mall when you tried taking the photos or outside on the street?
If the former, then you'd presumably be standing on privately owned property. I'm not knowledgeable about US laws in this regard, but you might need permission to take a photo in that instance?
Dunno :)
Cheers,
Dave
T
The Old Timer
In these days of lunatiks and wackos, I can see where someone at a Mall might become concerned if you were taking pictures. Who knows, you might be plotting a terrorist act?
True story from a long time ago. Back in the 1960s, when I was in the Marines, a friend of mine and another Marine were walking the streets of Philadelphia where the second Marine was trying out a new camera that he'd just bought. They were walking along (about 11:00PM) shooting pictures, and he decided to take a couple of snaps of a dairy truck. They hadn't gotten three blocks down the street when they were apprehended by several of Philly's finest, and without a word (pre-Miranda days, at any rate) dragged of to a holding cell. Three hours later, the legal officer and the executive officer from the Quartermaster Corps duty station came down IN PERSON to have them released. The police wouldn'r release them to "mere" MPs. (This was in the days of Chief of Police Frank Rizzo, who was three steps to the right of Saddam) We all found out later that the "dairy truck" was actually a camoflauged armored car. We never did find out what it was carrying....
-- John ___ __[xxx]__ (o - ) --------o00o--(_)--o00o-------
The history of things that didn't happen has never been written - Henry Kissinger
S
scottscottscott
Images have overlapping rights, and those rights are subject to interpretation.
Generally, you usually have the right to capture an image you see by painting, photography, etc, the same way you can sing a song in the shower as often as you want after you hear it on the radio. You don't necessarily have the right to capture the image w/o being impeded.
The copyright restrictions come when you actually use the image. The "fair use" doctrine allows discussion of the idea, image, etc. Models, owners, and copyright holders have their own rights to control and profit. Enormous legal practices are based on resolving the conflict between those rights.
One example is a pair of recent books about Beanie Babies. A price guide that had small pics for identification was found to be "fair use" of the subject images. A coffee-table type book that had big glamour pics was found to be infringing. The legal distinction was that the coffee-table book was a competing product with its subject; the price guide was a complementary product.
J
John Hairell
Generally in all U.S. jurisdictions if you are standing on public property you can take photos of anything you want, including people, unless the item you are photographing is copyrighted, in which case you may have an exemption under the "fair use" clause. There are also some exceptions which come under "espionage", i.e. you are not allowed to take photos of military and some other government installations. You can generally photograph people in public places, but if you are going to publish it is best to get a model release if that person's face is recognizable. Generally the rule is that absent a specific legal restriction, you can photograph to your heart's desire in public places.
AFAIK you do not have to compensate any businesses for taking photos of their premises from outside, even if you are selling the photos, and even if their lawyers send you threatening letters. If that were true commercial photographers would have to get rights to and pay to photograph anything in any built-up area. Generally any building in a public area or that you can see from a public area can be photographed without a legal problem. Certain buildings built after December 1st,
1990 may have been copyrighted, i.e. the design and look of it may be covered by a copyright.
If you are on private property (like a mall) and shooting photos you may need permission from the owners.
See
formatting link
for a more detailed run-down on all of the above. There are many other sites with legal info for photographers.
John Hairell ( snipped-for-privacy@erols.com)
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required
Report Content
You are reporting this content to the moderators. They will look at it
ASAP.