DCC: feedback in the loco - a dcc advantage

My origianl response to this thread/question has been adated to a separate
topic on fitting methods.
Below are my thougths on the original subject.
Phil: You could usefully consider dcc as providing a feedback controller,
optimally adjusted, right at the heart of the device you are wishing to
control: ie inside the locomotive!
Each dcc module*/decoder can be individually tailored to appropriate
maximum speeds, inertia, and starting voltage etc for each individual loco:
so that as the controller is moved to 'step 1' (which could be one of 14,
27,28 or 128 discretely requestable speeds - to which the decoder will
respond using maybe 256 internal speed steps, and changing with whatever
inertia you have specified - from none to heavy)
(*naming habit from Zero-1 days).
If you want back-emf control, then this can be optimally provided, or not.
- its your choice.
If you want directional lights, and integrated sound now or in the future,
then it makes sense not to progress down a blind alley which prevents this
being easily implimented (by remaining analogue)
If you are likely to modify your tracklayout, then 'classic' sectioanl
wiring is cumbersome, and may require a new design of control panel,
whereas with dcc just a paper drawing (or screen) needs to be redrawn.
If you already have sections on your layout - leave them, but just replace
ONE of you analogue controllers with a dcc unit: and switch on as many
sections as you wish that don't have an analogue loco parked on them
(although 1 analogue loco can be controlled - but it would be via the dcc
Modern h.f. decoders switch drive at above audio frequencies - allowing
'silent operation' and smaller components - suitable for all types of
Reply to
Loading thread data ...

Site Timeline

PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.