You are not getting enough grunt out of your power supply.
Try sticking a 10,000 micro farad across an unregulated supply. These will shift anything. No fancy electronics just passing contact switches. If you are using peco mounting bases there is a overposition spring in them as well as in the point blade positioner. One of them can be removed. I have been using my simple capacitor arrangement for years with out problem ( up to 4 points will carry). It helps to put a 5k resistor across the terminals to prevent retained charge on shutting down (leakage resistor).
Regards