Comment on this corrosion (Link to picture)

The manufacturer of an electrical water still has said that the failure
of the heating tube elements in their unit is due to the 3ppm of
chloride measured in the RO/DI feed water.
I have heard of stress corrosion cracking but a 40 mm x 5mm inch gash
after only 24 to 36 hours running time post installation seems extreme.
The manufacturer claims that while operating, the heating bundle was
fully submerged and at a max of 150°C . The heating bundle was installed
upright in a 12 inch column. The tubes are about 10 mm in diameter. Unit
was electro polished and passivated (citric type) before use.
Take a look at a picture of the corrosion using the following link. What
do you think the mechanism was for that kind of corrosion?
formatting link

Allan MacDonald
Reply to
Liz MacDonald
Loading thread data ...
Please use corrected link to picture
formatting link
My apologies.
Liz MacD> The manufacturer of an electrical water still has said that the failure
formatting link
Reply to
Liz MacDonald
Hard to be sure, but that kind of cracking is consistent with SCC. Which material is the heating elements made from? What is the tube sheet made from? Could contribute to galvanic corrosion.
formatting link
Reply to
Atlas Shrugged
Corrosion requires a combination of a material and an environment. What is the material?
Some stainless steels like Types 304 and 316 are relatively susceptible to chloride stress corrosion cracking at quite modest levels of chloride (5 ppm or so).
Go to
formatting link
and download publication 11021 (Corrosion and heat resistant alloys, aka High-Performance Stainless Steels). It is a 95 page booklet as a 1Mb Acrobat file. See Figure 65.
Pittsburgh Pete
Reply to

PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.