I promised myself that I would keep my big mouth shut about the various things going on in the world today and off the internet. But I think I'll break that promise and give my opinion. This is just my two cents, whether you agree with it or not. I have never been in a war zone, nor fired a bullet in anger. On the other hand, I'm active duty with 29.5 years the Coast Guard (we just lost our first Coastie in Iraq). I have been involved in more law enforcement boardings than I can remember, and have been involved in a few drug busts. I have been a boarding team member, and a boarding team officer. I have carried everything from a .45 cal pistol, 12 gauge shotgun, M-16 and stood behind a .50 cal machine gun trained on a suspect vessel. I feel that I'm as qualified as anyone to enter this conversation.
I understand why everyone is mad about the Iraqi prisoner treatment. I'm pretty pissed about it, too. With all the blood, sweat and tears shed by the real soldiers over there, the guards that were looking over the prisoners and abusing them cheapens what is being fought for there. I understand that they were told to "soften" the prisoners, or at least that was someone's claim. Well there are lawful and unlawful orders. Remember the My Lai massacre in Viet Nam? LT Calley who led the massacre claimed he had been ordered to do so by his superiors, but was found guilty as he followed an unlawful order (he was later pardoned). I would imagine that there would be a lawful way of softening" up the prisoners, without abusing them. Even some of our CG officers at work said that our treatment of the prisoners was nothing compared to the treatment of our people there. I wholeheartedly agree with them. But I told them first, two wrongs don't make a right; and that as American's we're supposed to be above that kind of crap. It cheapens what everyone else is doing, and dying for, over there.
Regarding the responsibilities of who was at fault; I suppose that you could say that both President Bush and Donald Rumsfield are guilty. Much the same as the captain of a ship is held accountable, even if he was not on the bridge, if the ship goes aground. One has to depend on your subordinates. They can make or break you. When they do good, it's reflected by you. When they screw up, same thing. But the reality of the situation is that I really don't see either the President or Mr. Rumsfield telling our troops to abuse the prisoners. I'm sure they would be interested in getting some answers, but some of the guards and their superiors got carried away. However, the pictures I saw of the male and female guard laughing at the Iraqi prisoners were having fun with them for their own entertainment, not for any military reasons. To say that I hope they get a reprimand would be a huge understatement.
Again, just my two cents...
Dave Young