OT: Woodstove

Oct 09, 2004 18 Replies
Jump to replies (18)

I just installed an epa certified wood-stove in my shop for supplemental heating. I've been disappointed with it's performance so far. I suspect part of the problem is me getting used to burning in these new type stoves.



The stove is installed in accordance with the mfgs. requirements, local and state codes etc. The stove is an Osburn Regal that is made in Canada. I have a 13 foot straight shot of black stove pipe up to the ceiling, and another 8 foot of insulated chimney above the roof surface. There is about 2 feet of chimney sticking above the peak of the roof.



The first issue I have is that this stove is spec'd to take a 17" log. In reality it takes a 15" log, 16" if you want to burn your hand up trying to wedge the log between the opening of the door. This situation is compounded by the small, tight firebox (even though the outside dimensions of the stove are fairly large).



While this is a pia, it won't be such a big issue when I start cutting my own wood and can cut the 15" length. In the meantime, ever try finding



14-15" firewood to buy? Not much of it out there, and most all rounds for sale are minimum 17". So I've been cutting 2" off my existing stock of 17" split wood. Not only is that a pia, it is not the safest thing in the world.

Anyway, not much I can do about the firebox size now. Lesson learned. I should have done more research on these new type stoves before buying. I purchased based on rated btu output and exterior dimensions of the stove, and believed the stated log size on the spec sheet. I liken this to the 2 man tent that really only holds one man. Or the 26 gun gun safe, that really only holds 23 if you don't want to scratch the heck out of your rifles when removing them from the safe.



On to the second problem I've been having with this certified stove. That is smoke out when starting and loading the stove. I get "puffs" of smoke rolling out the top of the door opening when starting the stove and when re-fueling the stove.



Not enough draft right? Well, it seems to me that the design of these new stoves complicates the whole draft issue. The firebox in this stove is completely enclosed, bottom, sides, back, and top with firebrick. In addition, there is a ceramic blanket that lays on top of the top row of firebrick, between the firebrick and the flue opening. When you look into the stove you cannot even see the flue opening.



Apparently the theory is the gasses and smoke are supposed to rise and roll out (towards the top of the door opening) and bend around the 180 degree turn and go up and over the ceramic blanket, finally making it's way to the flue opening at the center of the stove top. There is a pipe with holes in it right at that 180 degree turn that I think is supposed to burn off more of the gasses before they exit. I forget the technical term for that pipe... catalyst secondary burn or some such thing.



This seems to work well when the door is closed and the stove is burning. You can definitely see a bunch of gas movement and burning around this pipe through the glass door. It's a much different burn pattern then the old style stoves. Probably because on the old style stoves those gasses were just going up the chimney.



That doesn't help with the smoke out during re-loads though. Because there is such a very small and restricted area where the smoke has to travel. And because that travel path takes it right out to the top of the door opening and attempts to bend 180 degrees while it searches for the actual flue opening. The smoke usually takes the path of lease resistance, which is into the room.



When a fresh log is set in the stove, the fire bed is of course disturbed a bit. Causing smoke and ash to become airborne. With this sudden influx of smoke/ash the small opening for the draft to carry it to the flue opening is overwhelmed, and cannot take the volume all at once. So the smoke again takes the path of least resistance and goes into the room.



I liken this to the low flow toilets when they first came out. They didn't work at all. The volume of water was so reduced and the flow so restricted that the these things would clog if you just looked at them. I now have a "low flow" toilet, but it is pressurized and will suck the biggest turd down with ease.



Any ideas on what I can do about this smoke out issue? This is not a huge issue because the stove is in my shop. But I would be highly upset if I were trying to use this thing to heat my home. Still, I'd like to work in my shop without the smoke though.



What about a flue fan or something that I could turn on just before I opened to door to re-load? Maybe turbo charge the draft suction during the re-load and start-up processes?



Btw, I do use the crack the door open routine to help build the draft before fully opening the door. This helps but only a little. As soon as the door comes fully open the smoke rolls out in the room.



Thanks Wayne


Tell them to come and pick it up, you're returning it. If you paid with credit card, call them. Read fine print, if it does not function as advertized, the manufacturer and retailer are on the hook.

mj

I don't know the particulars of your stove but a couple of items to check.

  1. is there a bypass on the flue path in the stove used for starting the stove. Some have a bypass that connects firebox to the chimney directly for increased draft while building the fire. If so open this before opening the door. 2. Is the pipe to big for the stove. If the chimney pipe is to big then there is no velocity and poor draft. 3. You could try a venturi type cap on the chimney, the style that looks like windvane. 4. did the stove come with an instruction book and did you read it?

lg no neat sig line

Yes, I've read the instructions more times then I care to remember. There is no bypass on this stove. The only control is the air intake which I leave wide open for starting and loading of course. I purchased the stove new three years ago and am just now getting around to installing it. Because of that I doubt the manufacturer is going to be too helpful.

I'm tempted to just remove the ceramic blanket and two of the four top firebricks that are just under the flue. This would give the firebox a more direct path to the flue. Of course that would probably ruin the secondary burn and trash the efficiency. Might be better then using it as a very expensive, space hogging, table for my anvil though....

Wayne

---------------------------------------------------- Anything being cooked a second time needs a hot oven.

Is there any chance your shop is too tightly sealed to allow sufficient combustion air to be pulled in from the outside? It might be interesting to open an outside door/window when adding fuel just to see what happens.

Also consider adding a draft damper like those used on a furnace, maybe you can get your stack velocity up without it all having to run through the stove...

--Glenn Lyford

When starting, this can be standard (based on my slow combustion wood stove). It can take a while to get that draft sucking. I've recently switched to charcol+diesel+turps fire starters instead of messing with chips or twigs and that gets a draft going well (well it sounds like it). Just grab a handful of charcol and dump in half tin of fuel mix and allow to be absorbed.

When it is burning, open the flue (air control) to full for about 30 secs before you have to put the wood in. That gets the draft sucking.

On the otherhand, everthing in the same room eventually acquires a fine layer of ash after a while and it has us beat where it comes from.

I had the exact same problem, and I've gotten 90% of it licked. Here is what I did.

  1. Removed the blanket and one of the firebricks.
  2. Added an outside air inlet.
  3. Use a lot of wadded up paper to start the fire.
  4. Added a less restrictive chimney cap.

After trying to solve the last 10%, I've pretty much concluded that the stove is so efficient that the chimney is pulling too much heat out of the gasses, causing them to stagnate.

supplemental

I have used a wood stove to heat my house for the past 18 years. The pipe with holes that force some hot air down and across the glass is there to paint the front and keep it clean. It also burns the gas twice that way.

Now, When you open the door, the oxygen sucks in and the fire should flare. The fire or smoke should never come out the door, even when fully open.

Logs are supposed to be put in left to right. Not front to back. I burn short wood front to back but some are the other way as I build a bed of coals. Stoves are purchased on physical BTU sizes as a to large of stove is to cool for a good burn in a smaller room than what it is made for.

I use a medium sided floor sitter and it heats my entire house. The small size would heat the living, dining and kitchen but not the bedrooms and attic. (Yea we heat the attic as we have it converted into a storage and using loft of sorts.

  1. You have an obstruction in the pipe. A rat ? a twist ? Do you have an elbow to close to the stove ? - bends act as impedances to slow flow.

Try opening the damper full on. Is there enough air flow into it to burn ? Do you draw air from the outside into the bottom of the stove ? If not, the source is the house and runs out of air (and you do as well)...

Crack a window for a new source. Yes - let in cold air if needed. I vent in air from the basement into the bottom of the stove , the basement has open vents to the world.

I assume you have a new stove - just starting. If you installed it - is the metal inside the top - through the hole and maybe rock wool and such - in place ? is it clogging the works up ? It can shift around during moving.

Throwing in a new log should slightly slow the fire and then enhance it. I use green log (like a green limb) to cool the fire if to hot. No funny stuff should happen. It should smoke a little if he fire is cool already, and once the new one is hot it bursts into flames.

I think you have something plugged up somewhere. Outside pipe cover ? Is the screen filled with wax / soot ? that gets mine in this condition (typically during a rain storm) (I think the cap is chilled with the Pacific water dump and may help clog up the 1/4" holes at the wrong time.

A fan in the flue isn't needed - and won't survive long.

Are you burning pine ? - it might be so sappy that the resin is coating everything!

Mart> I just installed an epa certified wood-stove in my shop for supplemental

You did not say what the diameter of the flue is. With 21 feet of stove pipe you might need to replace some of it with larger diameter. I also have a wood stove in my shop. It has a very slight problem with smoke coming out the door when refueling. In my case the flue goes up about three feet, then goes horizontal for about eight feet and finally back vertical for ten or twelve feet. Much of that flue is 8 inch but there is a little that is 6 inch. I don't expect any problem with smoke out the door when I replace what is left of the 6 inch with more 8 inch pipe. Too much draft will not be a problem as I can control that.

Dan

I should say mine is an 8" pipe that is single wall (heat up the house nice) that goes up to the top of the A-Frame type open to the King Beam across the top. Just off center to give some more room to the other rooms.

The top is a nice large head with a screen 1/4" mesh to catch flying embers.

Any bend and any reduction of pipe is an impedance to flow. And perhaps the worse is to go 6" up to near the top and then go 8". Flow reduction and fast cooling off causes deposits.

In any case, I think there was air starved fire going on and the output was clogged up or to constricted. On new installs by non-store types, there might be issues of internal blanket that moved over a vent when it should be above the main top to protect the pretty outside top. Little things can make for a bad time.

Mart> You did not say what the diameter of the flue is. With 21 feet of

I've got about 9' of vertical 6" and don't have the flow problem at all. In fact, I can have the flue control valve almost closed before I start having smoke problems in the stove. The valve is about 6' from the stove which keeps most of the pipe hot and thus probably helps with the draft.

-- Why isn't there an Ozone Hole at the NORTH Pole?

On Wed, 13 Oct 2004 10:04:54 -0700, "Bob May" vaguely proposed a theory ......and in reply I say!:

remove ns from my header address to reply via email

I know it was only a sig line, but it's a good question. I had fun checking it out.

I was going to say that Northerners cause more Global Warming and that's why. Now I am not sure why it's warmer, but I was right about the warmth. It's because it's warmer. However, dear old H*mo "Sapiens" is working on it I believe. However he does have help....

formatting link
*****************************************************Have you noticed that people always run from what they _need_ toward what they want?????

My concern is these new fangled or over driven types are using in-pipe second burners like on a car. Normally bypassed until the fire is hot, then it is kicked in and re-burns the gases. This often (so I hear) gets clogged up and causes a problem.

The other issue on some in blackouts - the autoloaders for pellet stoves shuts down - so it needs a UPS backup for overnight issues.

Martin

For one thing, The South pole attracts different high energy particles than the North pole does. The poles are magnetic and other magnetic or electro-magnetic particles. Atoms and molecules have certain charge or magnetic field. Each also resonates at a unique frequency or set of frequencies - NMR principle. So the south is target to different stuff than the north. When the super nova went off in the small magnelgen (sp) clouds (star masses and fields) sent a shower of particles that performed three movements. Most slammed through the south pole. Some slammed into the north pole. Some zinged straight on and through you and I and the Earth.

Such is physics. Some say the way cards are drawn.

Martin

SNIP

Many years ago, I was in a garage in Northern New Mexico. The old fellow had a stove built of truck wheels welded together. Stood like a pot belly; loaded from the top. The keep smoke and flames from coming out when he reloaded, he had a steel brake line brazed to the stove pipe just below the damper. The brake line was angled upward and was connected to his shop air. Before he opened the door, he turned the air on just enough to give the flue gases a boost up the pipe.

Hey, just like modern gas furnaces. Only, his compressor probably cost less than the inducer fans. Hell, a new compressor costs less than an inducer fan.

Unless the air intake is in the door it should be closed just prior to opening the stove to stoke. Ramping up the firebox temperature before re-filling will help the draft. Regards. Ken.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required