Re: Scale Question Re: G Scale


>Some stuff is 1/24 which also is an odd ball scale.
>
Nuthin oddball about 1:24, its a nice simple half inch to the foot and
it is the exact correcxt scale for No 1 gauge to represent 3ft 6in
prototype track as used in South Africa, Australia, New Zealand,
Japan, Newfoundland etc.
But in the latest MR we have a review extolling the merits of a New
tramcar by LGB in 1:26, now that is oddball since it is both different
from all other known G scales and does not work out correct for the
track guage of the prototype concerned.
Keith
Make friends in the hobby.
Visit
Garratt photos for the big steam lovers.
Reply to
Keith Norgrove
Loading thread data ...
A nice thing about the large scale equipment is that you can do some amount of mixing of scales. European narrow gauge (LGB) doesn't look that bad with Bachmann (20.3) narrow gauge stuff if the American vs. European doesn't clash too much for you. And some of the newer LGB locos, like the Forney, are American anyway; LGB has several American pieces. Use of 1:29 or 1:32 "standard" scale stock looks OK with the smaller European or older US narrow gauge.
Viewers seem much more tolerant of mix and match scale with large scale layouts than they are with deciding that the drivers on the Bachmann Light Mountain are 2 scale inches too small.
Ed. in article snipped-for-privacy@4ax.com, Keith Norgrove at snipped-for-privacy@fiction.piplex.com wrote on 4/1/04 4:33 PM:
Reply to
Edward A. Oates
It does seem a bit odd-ball indeed. You can note, however, that it is EXACTLY 1/3 the scale, and therefore three times the size of HO (1:87). The story (that I have read) is that 1:29 was used for the original models so that the craftsperson could see the detail, which was then pantographed to a 1:87 model.
sdg
Reply to
scottNOgregorySPAM

PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.