I've just picked up a Crossley TSH2 which has an oiler with sight glasses filled (so I am told by the previous owner) with salt water. The salt is playing havoc with all the other bits in the oiler. My question is can something else be used instead? I assume the salt is in there as an anti-freeze agent.
A few pics at
formatting link
Regards
Dan
Didn't find your answer? Ask the community — no account required.
C
Campingstoveman
Dan,
Daft question should an oiler not have oil in it. Salt, water and metal is called corrosion surely. If they are empty then why worry about frost ?
Martin P
N
Nick Highfield
Presume they are the sort which 'drip upwards' if you know what I mean, I thought the usual filling was glycerine.
C
ClaraNET
That wasn't the one in the back of the latest SE by any chance was it Dan? Looks suspiciously similar! I was very tempted myself, only lack of room prevented it :-(
I think that the correct stuff to use in there is glycerine, available from your local chemist/pharmacist. Salt water was used as a cheap alternative, but its not nice stuff to have in a lubricator glass.
Regards
Philip T-E
P
Paul Evans
We use a salt water solution in all the oilers here without any bother.
Paul
-- ____________________________________
Internal Fire, Museum of Power, Wales
formatting link
(under construction)
A
Arthur Griffin & Jeni Stanton
Could one of our eminently erudite personages (evening Martin!) render an explanation of the principle of squirting oil through brine or glycerine. I've often wondered what the advantage of it is over a drip feed oiler.
Dan, like the engine. Someone's having a good Christmas!
Regards, Arthur G
N
Nick Highfield
I believe it's simply that the oil can be fed under pressure and therefore the sight glass can be positioned below the feed point (clearly a conventional drip feed must always be above the feed point). While I can see the advantage of this on large 'multi story' engines where it would enable all the sight glasses to grouped conveniently on the ground floor, I'm not sure why it was used on something the size of a TSH2.
D
Dan Howden
To answer lots of questions -
Yes it's the one from the SEM - I saw it and fancied another 'different and interesting' for the collection.
No, I can't afford it and haven't room for it....(but SWMBO hasn't noticed it in the conservatory yet!)
The Crossley instructions state saturated salt solution for the oiler, but by the state of them I shall be obtaining some Glycerine as the salt has already taken it's toll.
Regards
Dan
J
Jack Watson
This was an on-going little problem in the power houses in the 50's with the horizontal Rustons and Crossleys. Cleaning the sight-glasses was a bally nuisance. My boss set me the project of finding the best "solution" (koff).
Tried glycerine, salt water, all probable and improbable ideas, and eventually came to the conclusion that plain water was as good as anything. Preferably distilled or boiled, as it left less scaly crud on the inside of the glass tubes, although I think some of the crud came from the oil. It had to be scraped out.
Tried with and without the brass wire for the blobs to crawl up, found it better with. Tried a patent "waterless" plastic (perspex?) tube instead of the glass - seem to remember it had a black floating indicator thingammy jig, novelty value only, as the plastic tube became cloudy before long. (Think this was advertised in the "Mechanical World Year Book" of about that vintage? - must look that up)
However, there were no freezing problems there, so this might be a factor I did not need to consider.
(Tell us some more stories of the good ol' days, Grandpa.)
JW² in Oz Norton AntiVirus 2003 installed
************************************
D
Dan Howden
Thanks to all for the suggestions/info. I've just bought some glycerine (60p for a 38ml bottle!), so I shall try that. Initially as an experiment I may fill one of the two glasses with Glycerine and try salt solution in the other.
Regards
Dan
J
J K Siddorn
I really must be missing something here, why not use the standard antifreeze solution available from any motor factors? It is safe in aluminium engines, is alcohol based so will not attack mineral oils and is a pretty blue colour .
There. That's me neck stuck out - but I'm glad you reminded me, because I think there is water in the 1075 now I come to think of it!
Regards,
Kim Siddorn
- who wishes you and yours all the very best for the New Year.
B
Bob Spowart
Screen wash has methanol is to stop it freezing up, but engine anti-freeze is Ethylene Glycol based. At running temperatures alcohols would be too prone to evaporate.
J
J K Siddorn
"Bob Spowart" wrote
Ethylene Glycol used in antifreeze *raises* the boiling point of the water to which it is added. At 100% it has a boiling point of 387ºF (198ºC) and a freezing point: of 8.6ºF (-13ºC).
So the working temperature of an IC engine won't reach that high.
So (I'm sure I've missed something ;o)) ) - why not use antifreeze in the oilers?
Regards,
Kim Siddorn
- who wishes you and yours all the very best for the New Year.
R
Roland and Celia Craven
Because its blue and would clash horribly with a green engine? ttfn Roland
N
Nick Highfield
Perhaps oil and glycol are miscible (sp?) or glycol has a lower specific gravity than oil (don't know but would be quite easy to find out) in either case it wouldn't work.
M
Mike.H
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- See
formatting link
Mike.H.
M
Mike.H
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Available in a range of colours and clear. See beloow
formatting link
Mike.H.
R
Roland and Celia Craven
I presume the colours were chosen by the web designer :-) yeuch! ttfn Roland
N
Nick Highfield
"Peter A Forbes" wrote (snip):-
Clearly too wealthy by half, I have to settle for LBV or 'vintage character' ;-)
P
Peter A Forbes
Antifreeze attacks most paintwork....
Peter
Attacking a pile of mince pies and a nice vintage Port as he types..... :-))
-- Peter & Rita Forbes snipped-for-privacy@easynet.co.uk Engine pages for preservation info:
formatting link
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required
Report Content
You are reporting this content to the moderators. They will look at it
ASAP.