Interesting practice by my community college

No child will be left welding behind?

Hey, they're going to be welders. They have enough issues without feeling bad about their grades!

:-)

Cheers trev

When it's done like that it's usually meant to be homework and does not count as a test.

Yes, I think that it hugely helps with "assessment" results.

My conclusion is that the teacher's union will be patting themselves on the back for the good work.

STeve

My welding classes were generally not academically challenging in the least. Though we had a change of teachers over time, and the guy there now is trying to make the courses a bit more academically challenging, it's still fairly easy.

The first teacher gave open book tests for the mid term and final. All you had to do, was to be smart enough to find the answer in the book and write in the answer on the test. All the questions were taken straight out of the book. and they were multiple choice or fill in the blank. No easy questions. It was a test that only took about 15 minutes if you knew the material, but you had a full 4 hours to finish it. Most people could get an A even if they had never opened the book before simply by reading the three or so chapters covered by the test, and then answering the questions during the test.

And not to make it too hard, the questions were in order as they showed up in the book, so once you found one, you knew to read forward to find the next extra.

Most of the real grade came from the welding projects. If you didn't know how to do the welds before the class, it generally required you to show up and practice welding the full class to get everything done with a passing grade.

When I started teaching evenings at South Seattle, they told me I would have to give weekly quizzes, a midterm and a final exam.

What an absolutely ludicrous idea for an evening hobby welding class.

In 9 years I never gave a quiz, or midterm. My final exam consisted of 2 questions.

What is your name? What grade should you get?

Nobody at South Seattle ever bothered me about it. Every student who wanted a grade, got an A.

I never felt any guilt about it.

I enrolled in our CC's TIG class last year to improve my skills. The instructor admitted that he taught gas and MIG, but hadn't taught any TIG. I was spending one night a week 30 miles from home primarily helping to set-up, fixing machines, helping other students with less experience, and was providing the scrap metal for everyone to practice on, while learning nothing that I could not read at home. I hate to quit anything, but it was a waste of time. I did tell them they could come by and get scrap, but it's nearly 50 miles to the shop.

...

Perhaps they are meeting a requirement written by academic professionals who ignored hands-on manual training.

Maybe. We are finally getting able to do welding.

No different that the "courses" to get a private pilots license from many people. The test administered by the FAA is 80 of a possible 300 questions. The courses have all 300 questions and let you got through all 300 as many times as you want, or make up random 80 question tests.

Who cares if you aced the PP test, when the FFA guy gets you up in the bird, he'll figure out if you know how to fly...

I my opinion there is nothing wrong with this.

In a way, part of the "test" is to see if you took the tme to get a good grade, not just a passing grade...

At some point as an adult you finely figure out the only person you cheat is yourself if you don't really "learn". and if yer an asswipe kid, this will be your first object lesson in why you SHOULD have learned... The reality is that the test is for YOU, so YOU know what you've learned...

Grades in "trade school" or the any school for that matter don't mean squat, and ANY employer worth the money he's going to pay you will test you... just like the FAA guy...

So you say yer a welder huh... weld this while I watch (or have my best welder) watch... you open the Acetylene valve all the way, or dial the DC power up all the way .. he'll stop ya right there and say.. "Thanks but no thanks"...

So you say yer a computer programmer huh.. Ok Here's a hard problem, show me the code to solve it... If your code looks like " spaghetti ".. he'll say... Thanks but no thanks...

You do this to 10 people and pick the best one..

Been on both side of this fence, and I'l tell ya, you DON'T want to get me as the guy asking to see your program..

--.- Dave

I am usually the guy "asking to see your program" too. It is depressing how many people offer themselves for computer programming job and have no clue what is programming.

I believe firmly that some people are great at BSing their way through interviews and a regular chat type interview cannot filter them out. But asking to write a program, that is unambiguous.

What kind of programming questions do you ask?

I feel ya Dave, the last place a worked at decided they wanted to start giving "welding tests" to new hires. One of the bosses lackeys sets up a MIG, runs a bead on one side of a couple of pieces of 10 ga carbon set in a "T", hands the gun to the new guy and has him try it. ???? He then proceeds to bring the coupon over to my table, shows it to me like it was something. I picked it up. looked at it and said, "30 minutes". "What?" he says. "I can have my 14 year old daughter welding that good with 30 minutes of practice and she has never seen a MIG welder before. You want to impress me, turn the machine to 0, turn off the gas and let HIM set the machine up." I didn't have to talk to him for a couple of days. :)

Jim

Even that simple test, though, weeds out wannabes who never welded at all (or never MIG welded but said that they could MIG weld).

Whenever I gave a new hire a welding test, I'd give a demonstration. Then I'd turn the dials and walk away. Some got it, others came back complaining about "something's wrong with that GD machine."

look at it this way; if anybody does flunk the post-test, you can be sure that they really deserve to flunk.

i did the local adult ed night course (which is what started me on the road to this usenet group); unfortunately there weren't enough machines or enough scrap to go around, so I managed to get through the course and get a certificate, without ever actually touching a MIG welder; i spent half the time on a stick welder and the other half on the tig welder. (which was more fun, anyway). also one day doing acetylene.

but, that got me hooked and i bought a wire welder which is why i'm hanging out here. i don't think i'm going to take that certificate and get myself a welding job just yet, though.

i do like tig though. reminds me of all the soldering i did all my life.