OT: Democracy Connumdrum (?)

Feb 02, 2004 9 Replies
Jump to replies (9)

I just read two articles back to back in Sunday's paper. One was about the cost "of fighting terrorism". The other was that the state of Maryland will go ahead and use the Diebold electronic voting system (which is already bought and paid for) in the upcoming fall election despite the fact that a state commissioned study shows that the system is extremely vulnerable to tampering. I think Diebold is also the contractor for the Internet voting system the Pentagon wants to use for out of country DOD voters.



The cost of upgrading the system in time is too great. The study conclusion was that Diebold did not do a poor job in securing the system; they simply did not even take it into account on the physical or software level.



So, which is the bigger threat to a democracy? Those who would like to end American's lives early? Or, a voting system being adopted nationally that can have the tallies falsified by a high school kid and no tracks left behind?


The bigger threat? I would go with the high school student, though it does greatly reduce the political power of the PACs, DNC and RNC.

V>I just read two articles back to back in Sunday's paper. One was about the

We have used that system here in Georgia for several elections and it has worked extremely well. Even gets compliments from the little old ladies.

Maryland > I just read two articles back to back in Sunday's paper. One was about the

Neither of these appear on my radar.

I don't know of any american that views the middle east as an eminent danger to our way of life, whatever mix of terms you may want to apply, be it democracy, capitalism, "free", whatever, as long as you include "great".

I can only imagine the subsequent media frenzy and witch hunt that would follow a scandal such as you imply for voting systems. And that's what it would be, hardly a swing in our great nation's direction. Very much less a collapse of these United States.

The only thing that will bring us to ruin, if anything at all, is an extended period of despair. If you get enough people, hungry, homeless, and hopeless, then you've got trouble. Until then, we will continue to have our problems, and continue to be a force on this earth.

And, it's "conundrum".

I don't doubt that High School Hackers would get their licks in, early and often. I think, though, that knowledgeable professionals of both the major parties would be monitoring elections and attempting to make meaningful adjustments, right up to the final second of each election.

Harold Burton

What was wrong with the old paper ballot system where an INK pen was used to put an X besides the name of the selection chosen by the voter? No hanging chads, dimples or hacking to worry about plus they can be kept for recounts if needed. DL

Nothing, apart from the fact that it couldn't be used to funnel money into the pockets of campaign contributors. That's a MAJOR flaw as far as getting the system adopted goes.

The system wasn't broken before all these mechanical and electronic systems were invented. Now it is. Funny how progress works, isn't it?

I can see how having a fast electronic counting system might be nice, but without a voter verifiable paper trail for each vote there's no way to ensure that the system isn't being tampered with. There's no need for anything more complex than the old scantron forms. In practice the best we can hope for is a little printer attached to each electronic voting machine that prints out a ballot after we've voted. You check the ballot and drop it in a sealed box. In the event of a dispute the paper ballots trump the computer count. It's more complicated than it needs to be, but e-voting has momentum and money behind it, so it's easier to patch a crappy system than it is to do it right. People just don't care enough about this issue to overcome the lobbying of the voting machine companies.

For more information check out

......Andrew

Are you guys still whining about the 2000 bush victory. Geez, get over it :o). The FL Supreme Court tried to rig it, but the US Supreme court saw to it that justice was done. Greg Sefton

On Mon, 2 Feb 2004 10:34:45 -0600, "Harold Burton" brought forth from the murky depths:

Kinda like Flowda a couple years ago? ;)

------ We're born hungry, wet, naked, and it gets worse from there. -

formatting link
Website Application Programming -

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required