OT: skills shortage

Nov 22, 2005 136 Replies
Jump to replies (136)

What are these people smoking? There is a skills shortage the same way there is a gas shortage -- I just drove all over town and couldn't find a station selling any for 29.9 cents/ gallon.



Time for more H1b visas ......



Uncle George



===========================


Skills shortage plagues manufacturers


1 hour, 23 minutes ago

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - More than 80 percent of U.S. manufacturers say they cannot find enough qualified workers to meet customer demands, according to an industry study released on Tuesday.



While some 3.4 million factory jobs have been lost since 1998, the National Association of Manufacturers said employers are now struggling to find enough high-skilled machinists, technicians and engineers to keep production lines humming.



Of more than 800 manufacturers surveyed, 13 percent reported a severe shortage of qualified workers, while 68 percent experienced a moderate shortage.



"The survey exposes a widening gap between the dwindling supply of skilled workers in America and the growing technical demands of the modern manufacturing workplace," NAM president John Engler said.



The report, released by NAM, the Manufacturing Institute and Deloitte Consulting, found 83 percent of manufacturers were struggling to serve customers because there were not enough qualified workers. Some struggled to produce enough to meet customer demand, while others could not meet targets for productivity or customer service.



The exodus of baby boomers from the workforce, a negative stereotype of manufacturing and a drop in the number of U.S. students pursuing technical or engineering degrees are fueling the problem, Engler said.



Jeffrey Owens, president of Peoria, Illinois-based Advanced Technology Services, helps manufacturers fill the gap.



"It's a pretty significant problem," said Owens, whose 1,500 workers provide factory maintenance for heavy machinery maker Caterpillar Inc. (NYSE:CAT - news) and industrial and aerospace conglomerate Honeywell International Inc. (NYSE:HON - news), among others.



"A lot of people are retiring who are extremely talented, good people, and there's nobody coming in behind them ... The younger generation doesn't consider manufacturing a viable career alternative," Owens said.



NO CACHET



While the image of back-breaking labor in steel plants or on assembly lines may be what most Americans still think of when they imagine factory work, Owens said the modern workplace is often more about computers.



"You really use your brain a lot more than you use your back," he said. "There are some guys that can really work magic with the machinery to keep it running. Sometimes it's more of an art than a science."



While ATS has established a training program to lure students out of high school or technical schools and into a workplace where they can become multi-skilled technicians, experts say education in the nation as a whole is weak.



"Communication is needed between campuses and employers," said Cliff Waldman, a global economist at the Manufacturers Alliance/MAPI, a business research organization. "Companies have been remarkably innovative ... (but) the educational system has to work on instilling these skills."



NAM said its survey found significant dissatisfaction among manufacturers with the quality of kindergarten-to-grade 12 education and the dearth of adequate career counseling.



"We must update the image of modern manufacturing in the minds of young people, their parents and educators, and encourage more students to study math and science or follow a technical career path," Engler said.


Agreed-- These g-d news writers can make s*it smell like perfume...

Plus, I don't know if they can even follow their own logic, seemingly intermingling factory work, skilled labor, and g-d 'pyooters.

27c gas.... I remember it well....

Bottom line, esp. in the bigger cities, I think what we are witnessing is capitalism-gone-effing-wild, or perhaps more betterer, capitalism-turned-cannibalism. What I think is being "engineered" is that working muhfugguhs will soon

*never* be able to retire. So stay healthy, exercise regularly (yeah, and buy my Fitness Folly), eat yer veggies and take yer vitamins. Cuz yer gonna need'em, for dat 90 mile commute (to the factory?) when yer 90 years old.

Speaking of health, and perhaps jes slightly off-thread:

The real shortage of skilled workers is among medical doctors. Goodeffingawd.... Ahm off to see a bunch of these morons today, basically to fill out more forms. I mostly gotta fill'em out for them. And, of fukn course, I cain't jes drop sed forms off, I gotta make a

**bill-able** appointment. These muhfugguhs won't even return phone calls--come in for a bill-able appt.

These people are near-utterly useless. It is in fact the lab techs and the equipment mfr's who are doing the "medicine". Doctors are essentially just high-priced conduits for the info.

Altho this is starting to change--fukn ER doctors (the only useful doctors anyway) are starting to be paid by piecework. goodgawd....

Can you say, "Fish-in-a-barrel", boyzngerlz?

---------------------------- Mr. P.V.'d formerly Droll Troll

Hey, those CEO's have to make their 30 million dollar bonus.

I've been saying for years that there's a skills shortage in manufacturing. The availability of skills varies with short-term economic trends; but the overall decline is steady and dramatic.

Yes, I know, jobs can be hard to find for people with what seem like "main stream" experience and ability. So it looks, in some ways, like it's jobs (or decent pay, or decent working conditions) that are actually in short supply. But the most common skills in the metalcutting business are way, WAY short of what the industry really needs.

Five years ago (Five?? Good grief!) I posted something here for a young man who'd been running CNC machines, and was interested in becomming a real machinist. He thought he was good at his job; but was confused about what came next. And he thought that his "real problem" was how to get paid for his work and his increasing skill. I've dug up that old post and put it on my website, in case anyone's interested in what I think "Skill" ought to mean in the real world.

formatting link
There really IS a shortage. A big and critical one.

KG __ I'm sick of spam. The 2 in my address doesn't belong there.

I think there is a cycle in which power swings between corporations and labor, and the corporations have been on top for a long time, and that you will see an upswing in labor as a result. If I were a kid nowadays I'd join a good labor union apprenticeship program. Lots of skilled tradesmen make like $80k and live good lives without any fear their jobs will be exported.

GWE

Long gone are the high school shops where you learned drafting, foundry (remember the aluminum "foot" gas and brake pedals?), shear, brake, shaper, mill, lathe, arc, gas and TIG welding, bandsaw, cutoff saw, heat treat and grinders from bench to surface.

I still have the parallels, 1-2-3 blocks, sine bar and precision vise I made when I was 15 - 16 - 17, a couple chisels and center punches too. My high school shop class was better than most of the 2 year AA degree programs running today.

And, we were allowed to bring our rifles in and work on them too, just no handguns.

Try that today.

There is a skilled worker shortage in manufacturing and engineering because American society and culture no longer value those skills. Think about it, outside of government and military, what industry is growing their capabilities in the U.S.? GM just canned 30K employees, and the move to outsource jobs to Asia is now a stampede.

Traditional jobs in manufacturing are gone forever. There are still opportunities in niche markets for people with knowledge, life experience, and some chutzpah, but that leaves out most youngsters -- their only attribute is energy. Small, entrepreneurial companies can still do very well catering to the vanity of baby boomers, or the stupidity/rigidity of government purchasing regulations. But these tiny companies rarely hire kids with no experience because it costs too much to bring them up to speed.

Actually..in the machining trades..there are indeed a number of shortages.

The various layoffs over the years have forced many machinists into other lines of work, leaving a core group that are about ready to retire...and button pushers.

I could sell a brand new $40,000 OmniTurn lathe tommorow..if I can provide an competent setup man/operator to go with it, in Van Nuys California.

Talk about job security for someone..he would be hired to basily have his very own machine, with prospects for becoming the lead on a growing department as more are added.

Ive been looking for months for someone..no can find, as machine shops are enjoying a boom right now in So. Cal and many people are doing start ups of their own.

Gunner

Gunner

"The importance of morality is that people behave themselves even if nobody's watching. There are not enough cops and laws to replace personal morality as a means to produce a civilized society. Indeed, the police and criminal justice system are the last desperate line of defense for a civilized society. Unfortunately, too many of us see police, laws and the criminal justice system as society's first line of defense." --Walter Williams

I am curious, what is the pay that is being offered. It seems that this requires a level of qualification that is on par with some simple computer professions. I wonder if the pay is commensurate.

i

I've seen in the news from home that the owner of the company I used to work for mentioned outsourcing work to India and/or bringing people from other countries because he can't find enough employees. Six of us gave our notice in one week there. No effort at all to stem the flow of people leaving. Just a friendly reminder from the general manager that our jobs wouldn't be there for us should we ever be interested in returning and his reassurance that the company would be fine - he could be down to six employees and subcontract out everything and things would be ok. Not too long ago we were treated to a morale-boosting speech by the company president, who told us that firings-on-the-spot and pay cuts were coming our way. He told us we were the highest paid machinists in Atlantic Canada (and I'm not sure how he came to that conclusion). He then went on to say that he was going to make

7.5 million dollars next year, with our without us. At that point, any loyalty I felt to that company pretty much died and toying around with heading west was replaced by actively (desperately) seeking work elsewhere. I couldn't help but care about the work I produced right up until the end, but I had no interest in being there any longer than absolutely necessary. It's too bad, because I really did enjoy the work itself, and I really liked most of my coworkers. My partner worked at the same place, so we were totally on the same page as far as all that goes. Some of the guys who are still there are only hanging on because they can't convince their wives/girlfriends to move away and they can't leave them behind or because they have other family obligations. There aren't many machine shops at home. Three major ones I can think of (maybe 40 machinists each, but that's just a guess). One of the other ones isn't much better to work for, and the third does limited hiring. I had a job lined up there, but then we decided to make this move, so I had to turn them down.

For where we came from (high unemployment, a lot of seasonal jobs), the money we were making wasn't terribly bad. We were each around $12/hour. The thing is though, we dreaded going to work. We were doing four twelve hour shifts, getting paid no overtime (it worked out to 46 hours by the time you took off lunch breaks and they didn't pay time and a half until over 48 hours). There was overtime if we wanted it, but we worked opposite shifts and didn't want to trade off the little time we had together for overtime. We were living paycheck to paycheck. We lived in a trailer (my partner's dad and our five year old son lived with us too) with a small mortgage and owned two cars (an 89 Honda Civic wagon and a new Sportage) and two motorcycles (combined value under $2000). For two tradespeople we figured we should be doing a little better than that. I mean, we didn't expect to be living extravagantly, but we would have liked to have a few dollars left when the next paycheck came around, and even put some into savings. So...

We found out we could make twice the wages out here. There really is a shortage out here, and they're willing to pay good wages. (They were running ads in the newspaper at home, on the other side of the country) I've seen ads for places that are paying wages comparable to home, but we didn't have trouble finding jobs at around the $20/hour mark, to start. I'm working the weekend shift - three twelve hour shifts, getting paid for 40 hours. We're not paying $400/month for daycare like we were at home since we work different days. We still won't see each other much, but this is ok for now. When it gets to be too much we'll see about changing our shifts and finding a daycare or whatever. The thing is, we're still paying our mortgage at home, plus paying our bills out here, and we'll still be further ahead.

I don't know what our future plans are. Neither of us really wants to be this far from home. The plan is to pay off the mortgage and the Sportage and go from there. Maybe save up some money and start our own shop when we get home. We haven't done any serious research into that though.

Anyway, yeah... There is a shortage in some places (everyplace here seems to have a "help wanted" sign, from gas stations to grocery stores to machine shops), but the "shortage" in other places is just like you guys say, a shortage of people willing to work for low wages when they can make better money elsewhere.

As a footnote or whatever... We originally went to B.C. first, where we had jobs lined up, but the shop was on strike. They went on strike while we were on the way out. With no end in sight to it, we lined up some jobs in Alberta and came here. It seemed like everyone in B.C. was on strike - that machine shop, all the teachers, the phone company, I think CBC was still on strike at that time... The company we're working for started out in B.C. but moved to Alberta because they had so much trouble with unions.

chem (whew, sorry for the rant)

it's because of the notion in education that everyone must go to college to work at a desk or lab somewhere. they recently closed the last shop in the middle school my wife works at because the shop teacher retired and they couldn't find another one in the entire district (35,000+ teachers in the district).

regards, charlie

formatting link

Snipped

The company we're working for started out in B.C.

Chem, Nice post, you're in the running for the Kirk Gordan Award for brevity. :)

Sounds like your old boss was a real a hole!!!

You've found out that there are oppourtunities, all you have to do is search them out and be willing to take a risk.

Nice to get a more detailed update, and don't hesitate to ask questions or give advice, heck we even let Robin, another Canuck, post here.

:)

If you get the time in your busy day give us a shout on the IRC chat server.

Best, Steve

Don't make any serious decisions for a few years. Once you get to where you know where everything is, and have made a few friends worth having, you may decide the old environment is a good place to be from.

Later,

Charlie

Charles, You hit the nail on the head! In our local high school in California every student is being pushed or dragged to get what are called A-F requirements done as if they were all going directly to a four year college. It doesn't matter about their interests, ablities, or their economic condition.

Our high school closed our metal working shop a few years ago. The teacher and I along with others were in the process of getting the shop into the 21st century. We had gotten a couple of CNC mills in the shop and had the rug pulled out from underneath us by the administration. The shop teacher folded his tent and moved to a different city.

I find that few kids that don't want to go to college don't have the math or critical thinking skills needed to be a skilled craftsman.

And when they do get to college, they spend two years being forced to take expensive bullshit courses that the college, a business under any other name, forces upon them, and then two years studying whatever discipline they started with. Most dont even know why they are going, except that everyone tells them they must.

There are plenty of very successful people in the world who did nothing more or less than drive by a college and thumb their nose at it.

Problem solved! Here come a whole lot of skilled workers newly available to the job market! Wonderful, Huh?

formatting link

(snip)

Well not the guns bit but the metal shop that I volunteer (help the teacher and do other odds and ends jobs) at has welding, foundry, and machining (lathe-mill-bench work). Right now there are 3 basic and one advanced classes. So they aren't quite all gone. ...lew...

Jeez, make me glow.

I was hoping really to be proven wrong.

Where is your school located?

Cotter pin specialists, and axel nut specialists.

My old JHS had no fewer than 8 shops, including printing, ceramics, electricity, sewing, in addition to metal, wood, and a cupla others--cooking, crafts, stuff like that--wow.....

Printing was in the 8th floor "tower", and we, stupidly, would throw

48-point type (nigh-on a cubic inch of sharp-cornered lead!) out the window at our less-desirable colleagues in the playground....

Mr. "Tubbs", the pr>>

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required