Modelling a Zalman Heat Sink in Solidworks 2005

i initially modelled this in Solidworks, and it went pretty well. Not a perfect replica, but good enough for the task at hand.

i'm currently trying to "do it in pro-e". it's not going so well (i'm new at both s'Works and pro-E.)

i put some of the images online in a simple web page at

formatting link
with screen dumps from solidworks, pro-e, and one-space designer.

i thought the Solidworks folks might be interested in this comparison of the same medium complexity geometry, in 3 different "mainstream" solid modelling programs.

thanks !

wwswimming

PS a zalman heatsink is one of the best-performing heat sinks among the hundreds of different fan/heat sink solutions that are available in the PC marketplace. as far as "what it is."

Reply to
wwswimming
Loading thread data ...

I'd be interested to follow this, can't access your website though as I get the following error.

"The web site you are trying to access has exceeded its allocated data transfer" can you host it somewhere else?

Regards

John Layne

snipped-for-privacy@yahoo.com wrote:

Reply to
John Layne

hi

thanks for the heads-up !

i put up an informal mirror site at

formatting link
and

formatting link
i guess it's about a megabyte of images. i'm surprised i ran into bandwidth limitations.

Reply to
wwswimming

Any chance of getting a copy of the model? It would be of some use in understanding the complexity.

Regards

John Layne Solid Eng> hi

Reply to
John Layne

Sorry, I can't help you on the Pro-E front, but there is a MUCH simpler way to do it in SolidWorks... (that feature tree is scary!).

Unless I am missing something, you can do it in 5 features...

revolve cut extrude linear pattern another cut extrude and a mirror)

If I can work out how to post the model somewhere tomorrow night I will (unless someone offers to stick it somewhere for me??).

There are a couple of neat tricks you can use that folks around here might find interesting...

Cheers!

"John Layne"

Reply to
Aussie

OK. just would need your email. i think mine shows up on the Google news reader. but from your other post it sounds like you've found a more direct/ less circuitous route ?

wwswimmingyahoo.com

Reply to
wwswimming

PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.