Re: Model Buildings

Apr 01, 2004 2 Replies


Hello all.


> What is the groups opinion in ref to mixing different manufactures model
> buildings, albeit on different areas of the layout?
> My layout is a U-shape around the basement with an "island" in the middle.
> On the sides I am using superquick and metcalfe models with a few small
> wills scenic items thrown in, and am very happy with the result. However,
> for the "island" I have been collecting the Skaledale range and like them as > well.
> Would it best to stick to one type of building or do you think it will be OK
> to mix them? Anyone got any experience or thoughts to share?
> Rob

Frankly Rob, if it looks right, it *is* right! On a "real" train journey one would see thousands of buildings all built by different people in different ways, so if anything it's more authentic. :o)

I find that plastic (or other models with moulded 3-d elements) stand out when placed next to paper card buildings, the usual advice is dont mix them but I rather liked the effect when all the railway buildings were plastic but the set-dressing buildings (rows of housebacks along the rear of the layout) were the card type - One big plus of card is cost but with a bit of pratting about you can add a degree of relief detail, even a little goes a long way (recess doors and windows and add external window sills, doorsteps, drain and rain water pipes etc)

Mike

My advice is to try and keep a similar style of building whether they be card or plastic if you are modelling a village or small cluster of buildings. In towns you do see a wide variety of building styles, but go to a village or hamlet and the variety of styles is not so great.

I'm planning a layout now and buildings will feature quite a lot, but I want them to fit in with the imaginary history of the place being modelled, so I have to look at buildings constructed between 1930 and 1960. Anything earlier and it will have to be carefully placed and definitely outside the main area.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required