Hi,
Looking for a more secure lock for the exterior doors to my house. Have looked
at Sargent, Medeco, Schlage Everest Primus, Mul-T-Lock as well as some that seem
not to be readily available in the US, like EVVA and Abloy.
I'd just like to hear some opinions on the pros and cons of each of these locks,
as well as any alternatives I may have missed. Also, if I wanted to do install
something like an Abloy Protec deadbolt (for its claimed resistance to bumping)
or something similar, how would I obtain these in the US?
Thanks,
-Stian
Abloy are..
all you show above is 2 things.. key COPYING, and picking..1 of
which is not usually the problem..
instead..
1. house builder. get a NEW ONE... 'modern construction methods
SUCK, IMO any more'
2, do NOT let them use 'OFF THE SHELF DOORS'. ESPECIALLY THE
JAMBS already installed. there are both sizing and installation
problems with them..
3. windows..bad place to get broken out. so, they need changed to
more 'break proof' (film addition to make it somewhat more break
resistant)
4. then, look around.. like the TV show.. WHATS THE WEAKEST LINK
to get into your house. ''glass and doors' are usually high on
the list.. BUT.. SELDOM is a 'lock picked'.. VERY SELDOM..
and sometimes..its in plain site..
5 NO shrubs or big plants CLOSE to house
6, at that point THEN you can consider a better lock..
but..picking is STILL low on the list..
I opened a brand new house up once with a pocket knife and my
fingers..scasred teh CRAP out of the lady when i opened the door
without any fancy tooks..
gap between the door and jamb was about 3/8" and i just pulled
the jamb back a bit, took tip of pocket knife and popped the door
knob latch back about 1/16" and door was open..
can it be fixed? sure, but would REQUIRE a new door and jamb
unit, made a LOT better than what I see currently..
--Shiva--
forgot something.. if the doors open OUT.. make CERTAIN the pins
are NOT removable on the hinges, and that you got-whats the name
of the thing- inserts so the hinge pins cannot be sawed off and
the door pried out..
--Shiva--
Hi Shiva,
Thanks for the tips.
The problem of key duplication is in fact one reason I'm looking into the
higher-security cylinders. Most of the ones I've looked at are patent-protected,
and even though a determined person can still make a key out of a piece of
steel, that should at least deter casual copying at Home Depot and the like.
The biggest weakness at the house is in fact the windows and, worse, the patio
doors. Since replacing those with unbreakable glass is prohibitively expensive,
I'm thinking an alarm system is probably my best option here. Suggestions for
good patio door locks would also be welcome (I'm thinking about replacing the
sliding patio door with a conventional double door, which I could then put a
decent lockset on at least..)
I'm thinking about going with the Schlage system right now. They are fairly
reasonably priced, and I'd be able to do a master key system using Everest
Primus keys on entry doors and regular Everest cylinders on interior doors I
want to be able to lock. Seems to be the most economical option, and the Primus
system seems considerably better than the residential-grade Schlages that are
currently on the house.
Thanks again,
-Stian
ther are 'other' cheaper options IF that is your area of worry..
lets say ther are 4 levels of key copying..
1.. everyone can get the blank..the common house keys..
2. locksmith only available, in this case I am thinking LORI. has
a..'better than average' design for making it hard to pick 5 or 6
pin versions available. Locksmiths can get the blanks and can
copy, but AFAIK the 'hardware stores' cannot buy into them.
3. a 'locksmith owned' key blank.. 2 levels here, for your
explanation.
Winkhaus is one such company.. the 'lock shop' buys the rights to
the 'blank' and he is the only one around within X states or
miles, that has THAT blank..there are many different blanks,
but.. only the right blank will insert into your lock..
or
4. the ones you listed..Assa, Medeco, Schlage are usually
'locksmith owned' key ways.. to get copied you go to the ORIGINAL
purchase place. I have for instance 2 large Assa dealers east of
me in the same town..they each 'have different key blanks'..so
that the keys will not interchange between the 2 dealers.
look into the 'film' that you can add on to the glass- beats
French doors in price IIRR. easily installed too.
depends on the existing door lock..
NOT CHEAP..
back to your glass.. stop it from being pried UP..and stop it
with a..want to say the name of it is a 'charlie bar'.. a solid
bar that folds down between the sliding door and the wall it
slides TO. there are also available 'sliding bolts, keyed to your
house key that can be added to these that will help.
yeah, A grade knobs are better than the F grade or S usually
used
alarms have weaknesses.. BUT..
no pets?
then you want a 2 system alarm..motion sensor plus magnetic
switches in some areas.. glass breakage sensor and motion in
others, as needed..or, a similar AS THE INDIVIDUAL area
dictates.. wired so that they cannot be bypassed WITHOUT
tripping.. IE-sometimes the alarm company wants money and doesn't
give the best possible value..
--Shiva--
"Stian Oksavik" wrote in message:
Unauthorized key duplication is a problem, but that doesn't
necessarily require you as a homeowner to install super
expensive "high-security" locks like the ones you have
previously listed... I like the LORI deadbolts -- you can
key them into any system you can get in a mortise cylinder
and they are plenty strong for residential applications...
You can get an Assa, Abloy, or Medeco door lock if you
wish, but one day you will come home to your door
being strewn about in little pieces, and your intact lock
resting on the floor... Residential doors just DO NOT
withstand a determined attacker wishing to make entry...
A "decent lockset" will not keep burglars out of your home...
Not as long as there are glass windows installed... You
have to think of target hardening -- "Urg" the caveman
burglar will smash glass to gain entry, VERY FEW, if any
burglars PICK locks to gain entry... Those very few
extremely professional burglars that DO pick locks, are
stealing things from people that shouldn't have them
in the first place [ i.e. they stole the thing originally, OR
it is illegal to possess the item(s) that were stolen from
the home by the burglar] and therefore are MUCH less
likely to have the crime reported on them and ever be
caught...
"Decent locksets" will do nothing to alert the police that
someone is attempting to gain entry into your home...
An alarm system can -- and an alarm system can be
tied into such wonderful things like smoke detectors,
carbon-monoxide detectors, and water leakage sensors
for your basement that can alert you to safety issues
in your home that you may be UNAWARE that are
taking place while you are HOME... Don't cheap out
on an alarm system -- the nice "wireless ADT" systems
are very cheap to install but require maintenance --
those pesky batteries need to be changed...
Primus are "better" that residential grade locksets,
this is very true, but a Primus lock installed on a
plain old ordinary residential door with nothing else
doen to it is just a foolish waste of money for a
false sense of security... You DO NOT need to
install such locks on your home, as your "problem"
is curbing unauthorized key duplication... Using
LORI deadbolts on your doors will allow you to
install commercial cylinders in the door, and you
will find that there are some fairly obscure standard
commerical keyways out there that BOTH Home
Depot and the local hardware store have NEVER
heard of nor seen before, that a locksmith can
obtain for you... You can make these cylinders
"more diificult to pick" by asking the locksmith
to use spool driver pins...
Evan,
~~ formerly a maintenance man, now a college student...
lots of things come into question but for a normal
residentual instalation,
I would just go with Schlage.
order an ood keyway like "F" or "G" for key control.
those are keyways that is probably not stocked by your
loccal key duplicater.
also,
would put the same effort in beefing up your door jam
construction.
have your local Locksmith order it for ya too.
my2¢
Schlage F blanks are on the hardware store rack, can't remember the curtis
number. SC9 and 10, or something. Schlage E blanks also at the store.
G would be better, or the 1468 keyway if you can get it. Or CE, maybe.
Problem is, I don't think those are available in F=line knobs.
"Bud--" wrote in message:
Contact a local alarm company for a home security/safety
evaluation... Many companies these days will do a survey
and offer a quote...
Having worked in maintenance/security for several years
before going on to college, I can say that there is no
single "brand" of alarm panel or device that is better than
any other... They all do the job when they are installed
properly...
It is the way the system is designed to fit your home and
unique security needs and therefore how it protects your
home that makes the alarm system effective... There is
no such thing as a "cookie cutter" alarm system kit that
can be used to protect your home...
Not having done any kind of residential alarm work, I am
unable to give any specific suggestions...
Evan,
~~ formerly a maintenance man, now a college student...
NOT a DIY project..IMO.
yes, its PHYSICALLY possible to do it.. but, you, not doing this
for a living, might overlook something that should be done in a
different way to cover possibilities that you didnt think of..
plus in some areas, alarm systems MUST BE installed by 'licensed'
inspectiors..and have a permit even to be used..
--Shiva--
STOP!!
DO NOT ATTEMPT TO DO THIS YOURSELF!!! Installing locks requires the skills
of a trained Locksmith and attempting this procedure yourself will more
than likely result in a botched job
You need a person like this guy:
formatting link
See all of those key blanks?
They may all look alike to an untrained layperson, but once you know the
inside secrets of the Locksmithing trade, you can unlock the potential in
each one of those blanks.
HTH
Well, without people, you don't need security. I spent time in a remote
area one summer, no locks necessary.
But your theme is correct. Burglars don't even pick Kwikset which a child
can pick in seconds. I did when I was a child.
Burglars smash and grab.
with regard to home cylinders, why not make it possible to secure your home
with only ONE cylinder from the outside.
That's what I do. I was thinking about this the other day walking by
Fashion Show Mall here in Vegas, and they have maybe 6 doors all equipped
with high tech cylinders. Just in one section. There might be dozen or
more sections. What a waste. Why not make them ALL lockable but not
unlockable from the outside????
I don't get it. Hundreds of entry points each with a lock. Why not one,
two maybe, three at the absolute max.
I bought a really nice new Medeco grade 2 leverset from ebay for 40 bucks.
Had 2 keys with the square bow featuring a guy with a rifle. Hard to
duplicate without a card I'm told. Well if they both get lost, that's life
I guess.
"billb" wrote in message:
Yes, but what seems like a waste to you, is a fire code
requirement for many larger commercial structures...
Just think of how long it takes to "walk around the long
way" when outside one of the exterior entry doors you
propose making "lockable from the outside, but not
unlockable"... Not every stiuation to which the police or
fire department responds to calls for or justifies the
damage of property in order to gain entrance...
What use is an external entry point on a large building
that can not be opened from the outside ??? My guess
here is that you have NEVER worked in a large shopping
center doing either maintenance or security, so you just
don't understand nor foresee the random need to be able
to open a door from the outside at ANY point around the
building's perimeter at ANY time...
Until you walk a mile in the shoes of someone who would
have to live and work with only three accessible exterio
doors on a building with hundreds of them -- one shouldn't
make such sweeping generalizations... If only ONE of those
hundred doors ONLY ONCE resulted in being able to mitigate
some situation before it became "out-of-control" and therefore
allowed the employees to minimize damage or save a life, then
having them all there is perfedctly justified...
An old proverb seems appropriate here:
"For want of a nail [or -- an exterior door capable of being
unlocked/opened from the outside] the kingdom was lost..."
Evan,
~~ formerly a maintenance man, now a college student...
PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.