Nope. I never mentioned the veracity of the quote. Check the time stamps or get a real newsreader.
My post was:
"Betcha a bagel he doesn't respond at all- that's his way of dealing with anything he can't refute.
-Carl"
-Carl
Nope. I never mentioned the veracity of the quote. Check the time stamps or get a real newsreader.
My post was:
"Betcha a bagel he doesn't respond at all- that's his way of dealing with anything he can't refute.
-Carl"
-Carl
I thought DFW was a major one and Houston and the Austin-San Antonio metro area.
Martin
arsenal 1. A governmental establishment for the storing, manufacturing, or repairing of arms, ammunition, and other war materiel. 2. A source of supply for arms and other munitions. 3. A stock of weapons.
armory 1. A storehouse for arms; an arsenal. 2. A building for storing arms and military equipment, especially one serving as headquarters for military reserve personnel. 3. An arms factory.
- American Heritage Dictionary, New College Edition, 1976
Id didnt ask you for interpretations, I asked a simple question. Is the statement true or not?
"No man shall be debarred the use of arms. The laws that forbid the carrying of arms disarm those only who are neither inclined nor determined to commit crimes. Such laws make things worse for the assaulted and better for the assailants. They ought to be designated as laws not preventative but fearful of crimes, produced by the tumultuous impression of a few isolated facts, and not by thoughtful consideration of the inconveniences and advantages of a universal decree." - Thomas Jefferson
Main Entry: ar·mory Pronunciation: 'ärm-rE, 'är-m&- Function: noun Inflected Form(s): plural ar·mor·ies Date: 14th century
1 a : a supply of arms for defense or attack b : a collection of available resources 2 : a place where arms and military equipment are stored; especially : one used for training reserve military personnel 3 : a place where arms are manufacturedSpringfield rifles were manufactured in Springfield Arsenal.
I agree that the term is used by the ill informed, but they are the same people calling a detachable magazine for a weapon, a "clip"
Search the dictionaries for Clip..and you will likely find it to indicate a magazine, where in fact it is a device to load a magazine.
Gunner
"No man shall be debarred the use of arms. The laws that forbid the carrying of arms disarm those only who are neither inclined nor determined to commit crimes. Such laws make things worse for the assaulted and better for the assailants. They ought to be designated as laws not preventative but fearful of crimes, produced by the tumultuous impression of a few isolated facts, and not by thoughtful consideration of the inconveniences and advantages of a universal decree." - Thomas Jefferson
Well I hear the gunshots every night in Dallas. Does no good to call & report it (just normal for Dallas) :(
The point is, if Ed cannot be convinced by phony trumped-up statistics and flawed logic, and he's on *your* side, then what good is this stuff going to do when applied where it really matters?
Jim
================================================== please reply to: JRR(zero) at yktvmv (dot) vnet (dot) ibm (dot) com ==================================================
*Efforts*.
Hmm. Now that would make sense - not really a federal matter.
Jim
================================================== please reply to: JRR(zero) at yktvmv (dot) vnet (dot) ibm (dot) com ==================================================
I can't imagine anything you wouldn't bother to debate about, Ed :o). Greg Sefton
You ought to take your own advice first, Richard, or learn to use your browser a little better. You did make a tedious mess of it with your arbitrary selections of which states you'd count and not, but they can be untangled.
First, a reminder of what we're talking about:
The list of states you included as "open carry," seems to be one somebody cooked up to make a point. The list I used was one posted on the Packing.org site, which was footnoted, and I threw out the questionable ones with a lot of exceptions indicated in the footnotes, to give the benefit of the doubt. Then I checked them against "Survey of State Procedures Related to Firearm Sales, Midyear 2001" (since I was using 2001 FBI figures), published by the Bureau of Justice Statistics, to see what the purchase restrictions were. I wound up with 27 states that sounded reasonable. Finally, I checked the open-carry policy of footnoted states against Packing.org's report to see if the list accurately reflected the states they consider "open carry." They did. THEN I looked up the FBI numbers of murders per state and attached them -- after I had selected the states. I sent the list to Larry Jaques who can confirm that it's just the list of states without the ones that had all the footnote qualifiers. (You can see the footnotes at the bottom, Larry, but I stripped those questionable ones out before adding up the numbers, and that's the list I sent to you.) Since I worked from a list of open-carry states, and NOT from a list of restricted states, the District of Columbia was included in my "not-open-carry" list by default.
It looks like you did just the opposite -- stretched your criteria when it worked to the numerical advantage of your assertion. For example, you included Utah as an "open-carry" state, noting that you did so even though it has "some strict restrictions." *I'LL* say they're strict. For example, the gun can't be loaded...
========================
Utah penal code 76-10-505: Carrying loaded firearm in vehicle or on street. (1) Unless otherwise authorized by law, a person may not carry a loaded firearm: (a) in or on a vehicle; (b) on any public street; or (c) in a posted prohibited area.
========================
The "otherwise authorized" means one who possesses a CCW, or an officer of the law.
It's funny you would include that one, which so obviously fails Ford's criteria, until you note that Utah had only 43 murders in the year you counted. Hmm. 'Sure helps the overall numbers, eh? And that number really is low. Maybe it was because it's hard to murder someone with an unloaded gun...unless you club him to death with it.
Of course, Ford's statement is nonsense from the get-go, because there is nowhere in the US where "anyone can buy a gun, strap it on," etc., because of the required federal background check and excluded categories of purchasers. And many states, including some of the "open-carry" states, have added further restrictions to who can buy a handgun.
But you've made more arbitrary distinctions here, and they're no more consistent than the case of Utah. You throw out Missouri as an "open-carry" state because of "permit to purchase etc. etc. etc.," but the "permit" is only a piece of paper that carries the same data, and that requires only the same check, as those of the dealer-check states. There's no safety training, no fingerprints; it's just a piece of paper one gets because Mo. has decided, like some other states, to do the background check at a police station and to issue a "permit" that the buyer hands in at the gun store to show he's gone through the federally mandated check.
If that's supposed to be some kind of unacceptable restriction, then what is it? Or is there something in the "etc.'s"? Missouri has a new preemption that cleans up most of the "etc's" except for local laws on open carry; but then, so does Virginia, which you put in the "open-carry" column. Virginia has grandfathered-in, no-open-carry municipalities, those which passed laws prior to 1987, which make it about as "unpure" as Missouri is (not to mention that Virginia has a one-handgun-purchase/month restriction, which Missouri doesn't have). Why is one in each column, then?
Remember that ALL states are more restricted than "Ford" said. Distinguishing the open-carry restrictions of Missouri as substantially different from those of Virginia, or disqualifying Missouri's paperwork that's used for certifying the passing of a background check because it's a "permit" system, as if it was like the one NJ has (that's a REAL permit system), is ludicrous. Until, of course, you note that Missouri had 372 murders. Then perhaps we get a better idea of why you made the arbitrary distinction. Virginia has a very high number, too. Maybe you didn't want to make it obvious by throwing both of them over to the other side.
And while we're on that, you said "Wisconsin has no open carry restrictions that I could find," (though you didn't have trouble finding that relatively low murder figure of 169) but you said nothing about the 48-hour waiting period to purchase a handgun. So, carrying a piece of paper from police station to dealer, as in Missouri or North Carolina, disqualifies those states as purified "open carry" states, but a 48-hour waiting period is Ok? That's not a purchase restriction in your mind? If you're going to get fussy about states that do a background check at a sheriff's office or police station and then issue a piece of paper on the spot, versus those that do their background checks electronically at the dealer but that then make you wait two days to buy a gun, then what is the meaning of making the "permit" distinction in the first place? If you'd left it at NJ and NY, you'd have a case. As you've done it, not...except that it gets more of those nasty murders out of the "open-carry" column, eh?
There are more examples of silly distinctions you've made, and I wouldn't bother except that the overall effect was to get a LOT of murders into the not-open-carry column, and that in some cases that appears to be the only reason you put them there. Michigan (672 murders in 2001) is interesting: it's open-carry, but they have this little gun-safety quiz they give you, on which you have to get 70% right, or you don't get your handgun. Another nasty permit. If all of those people who are too dumb to know which end of a gun the bullet comes out of were only allowed to buy handguns and carry them around on their hips, unfettered by this anti-gunner nonsense, Michigan, too, would have vastly lower murder rates. It isn't the marginally intelligent people who passed the test who are going to save Michiganders from violence; it's all of the truly stupid ones who couldn't buy a gun! They're our real saviors, and we've hog-tied them from fulfilling their heroic destiny with a safety quiz that any semi-sentient moron could pass, but which they couldn't...
The logic of "Andrew Ford's" assertion is an abortion. You're trying to defend it on hair-splitting grounds, and not very well at that, so I'll say again, on equally hair-splitting grounds, what I said before: he's either a liar or a moron. Even with your cherry-picked states as examples, as you said yourself, you only came up with a 1/4 fraction. I said it was 1/3. Ford said 1/5. By your measure or mine, even on that literalist basis by which you've defended him, he's still full of it.
But that's not the real deception in his quote, which first counts his fractions of the country by counting states, and then counts his fractions of the murders by counting people, suggesting that his "half" and his "4/5" are measured on comparable terms.
Who's crazy? Maybe Ford. Maybe the people who believe his point has any merit. Maybe people who never thought seriously about logic. Maybe the people who defend his obvious deception by splitting hairs in a grammatical exegesis, and who think that's an honest way to settle an argument.
The significance of the issue really is a sorry one to begin with. To suggest there's any relationship between a state's open-carry laws and crime rates is an incredible stretch, first, because so few people strap guns on and walk around "the streets," anyway. A note on the Packing.org site from a guy in Kansas, says it all: involved enough with guns to have written to his local sheriff for an explanation of open-carry, and to have posted the Sheriff's reply on the Packing.org site, he notes at the bottom that, in his
20+ years he's lived in the state, he's never seen anyone open-carry a handgun.So much for "crazy."
Ed Huntress
Very complicated, unfortunately. If you're employed by the magazine to write, and if you have no other deal written into your contract, the magazine owns all rights. (I suspect that George Will had some kind of contractual deal that shared copyright, but I don't know.)
If you aren't an employee of the magazine, or if you are but you aren't one who is *employed* to write, and if nothing else is said between you and the publisher or his designated agent (the Editor, usually), then, when you submit an article, you're offering First Time North American Serial Rights. That means the magazine gets to publish it once (and you can't sell it to someone else who's going to publish it before the first magazine publishes it), and then the rights revert to you. The magazine usually will grab more rights for themselves by making your cashing their check contingent upon granting them the rest of the rights. Or, they used to. I haven't followed the courts on this. I haven't freelanced for most of the last decade.
BTW, if the rights should revert to you, that doesn't mean you can reprint the magazine article as a facsimile (a photocopy or offset copies). The magazine retains the rights to the format and the size, placement, and modification of any illustrations, so they effectively own their own pages. But they can't reprint them, either, if they don't have the rights to your copy.
Aren't you glad you asked?
Yup. You can negotiate anything. Watch out for electronic rights because cases are still being fought in the courts over it. For now, electronic rights appear to revert to the author, by case law, unless otherwise stated in the contract.
They're different in default, because the book publisher has the right to reprint. But book contracts, unlike magazine contracts, are almost always explicit in the contract itself. And, once again, that's negotiable.
You may notice I don't argue religious beliefs (although I sometimes debate religious history, because it's history), that I don't advocate political candidates or parties (I'm a Republican, but I don't always vote that way and I don't care much which way anyone else votes, anyway), and that I'll usually stay out of a reasonable and balanced discussion on controversial subjects. The thing that draws me like a moth to a flame is propaganda or unanswered, misrepresented "facts" in a controversial discussion. When I see them, I light up like a fuse.
Ed Huntress
more useless bullshit....
Sure thing Mabu.
What was that definition of "pistol" you used to quote in here?
ral
Lets toss this into the mix
Most dangerous states by ranking
"No man shall be debarred the use of arms. The laws that forbid the carrying of arms disarm those only who are neither inclined nor determined to commit crimes. Such laws make things worse for the assaulted and better for the assailants. They ought to be designated as laws not preventative but fearful of crimes, produced by the tumultuous impression of a few isolated facts, and not by thoughtful consideration of the inconveniences and advantages of a universal decree." - Thomas Jefferson
Correct, why would they attempt to restore the voting rights of people whom would vote Republican, if the felons tended to vote that way? We both know its not altruism ....snicker
"No man shall be debarred the use of arms. The laws that forbid the carrying of arms disarm those only who are neither inclined nor determined to commit crimes. Such laws make things worse for the assaulted and better for the assailants. They ought to be designated as laws not preventative but fearful of crimes, produced by the tumultuous impression of a few isolated facts, and not by thoughtful consideration of the inconveniences and advantages of a universal decree." - Thomas Jefferson
I am NOT going to get involved in this debate! However...
I've often thought that if people are going to carry guns, then they should be REQUIRED to carry them openly, visibly; and should not be allowed to conceal them. If we can all tell that someone is armed, just by looking at him/her, then each of us can make better, more fully informed decisions about our own behavior. (If Jehova's Witnesses knock on my door at 7:30 in the morning, and they're all wearing gunbelts and
357's, then I'm a lot more likely just to pretend I'm not home than to open the door and chase them away. If the weapons are concealed, however, and if I open the door and let the dog out, and THEN learn that the JW's are packing, things could get ugly.)It seems to me that a concealed weapon is more of a problem, and should be more of a concern than, say, a rifle or shotgun clearly visible in the back window of a pickup truck. I never think twice about that, when I happen to see it. The gun-owner is probably a farmer, or a rancher, or someone else who benefits from being able to prang a groundhog or a coyote when the need arises. Same with the handguns worn by cops. I know they're there. I know there's a reason for them that has nothing to do with threatening me. And I don't mind a bit.
Someone who wants to protect himself could probably, in most cases be better protected by announcing himself as armed, rather than by concealing his gun and looking like unarmed prey to a prospective criminal. Surprising the criminal might be fun or satisfying for someone who doesn't get killed while trying it; but it can't possibly be the best way to be safe.
When someone conceals a weapon, then it makes perfect sense for others to question the reason for the concealment, and the real purpose for which the weapon is intended. If I have to make the choice, I'd rather see "Open Carry Mandatory" laws, with VERY stiff penalties for concealment, than wasted attempts to outlaw guns that we don't even know are there.
And, if guns were as visible as, say, cigarrettes, then I suspect we'd do a much better job of policing ourselves through the time honored practice of "social pressure". My sister-in-law's house is an absolute no smoking zone. It's her house, and she has a right to make the rules, and everybody in the family knows it. And, SHE'LL know immediately if I decide to unwrap a cheap cigar and light up in her living room. If I did the same kind of thing, and decided that my home was a gun-free place, then anyone who wanted to visit, or some young man who came to pick up my stepdaughter for a date, or the delivery people bringing my new sofa, would have to make the same kinds of choices that smokers do, since their weapons would be as easy to detect as a plume of smoke. Better yet, I could do this WITHOUT having to limit the rights of any person to be as armed as he/she cares to be. I'd only be exercising my own right to detrimine what goes on in my own house.
The results of peer pressure and widespread social disapproval of smoking have been pretty astonishing, and have developed pretty quickly, as large scale social trends go. I wonder if the public wearing of visible guns, even if completely legal, couldn't be moderated in the same way, and for very similar reasons.
KG
I think you just did.
I hear the cavalry coming over the hill as we speak...
I'm going to go see if the path back to the fort is clear. You hold them off.
Ed Huntress
I have, too. We can agree on something.
Discussion over.
ral
Thanks, Ed - nice explanation. I don't think we're paying you enough.
R, Tom Q.
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Ask the community — no account required