OT: Read Gore's Speech

Nov 12, 2003 181 Replies

He wouldn't have any standing to file suit (though, ironically enough, he would have standing to file a constitutional claim that his right to travel and/or right to privacy was infringed by the random strip-search at the airport--not that such a suit would have merit). Merely being aggreived at the unconstitutional nature of a law is not normally sufficient to allow one to have grounds for a suit challenging it. Now if identity cards had been part of the Patriot Act, every last one of us would have had grounds to file suit, since it directly affects all of us. Again, whether such a suit actually has merit is quite another issue--the standing to make a claim is only the first hurdle of many in a constitutional challenge.

Mark Schynert

Well, Vess, far be it to from me to disagree, since I'm more liberal than you (it appears) and everyone knows us poor wimpy liberals never stand up and fight when we can instead stand behind principles, not to mention big tough Marines in harm's way.

Yasser Arafat is absolutely an elder statesman, I guess. The trouble is, you've now managed to drain all value out of the designation, and tar Gore from the terrorist pot. Thanks a bunch.

Mark Schynert

You really need to look up the menaing of the word "fear" and then the word "revulsion" and then use the correct word.

Fortunately that only applies to some liberals. Others are of the Michael Totten or Norman Geras variety and widely respected by conservatives.

Heh. Even *I* wouldn't paint Mr. Gore with the same brush I'd use on Arafish...... ;)

Welcome to Reality 101.

That's always a risky proposition..... ;-p

Really?

Scott G. Welch 'Send us some guns...there's a wheen o' Injuns about.'

Liberal Scots-Irish dirt farmer, in letter to relatives in Ulster, c.1800.

Sorry, but I don't share your enthusiasm for the wisdom of Al Gore. Nice enough fellow personally, as you've pointed out, but an ex-Veep nonetheless. In my irrelevant opinion, one good speech does not an elder statesman make.

Al Gore's ideological soulmates 'over here' are cooking up their own plans in the civil liberties arena. Some of the stuff that's proposed for in the US they do here now anyway. If Al was in power, chances are he'd be trying something similar.

People are about as likely to forget that one as you are to give GWB's service record a rest.

Scott G. Welch

LOL!!!!!! Hardly......

How about we call you stupid and leave it at that?

Impressive to be a fool, well, if it works for you. A rare tallent to be appreciated? Not according to the posted comments by my fellow modelers.

Meanwhile, back to modeling

Just to numerous to mention, and I do hate to brag. It makes one look small in the eyes of their peers.

Does the "sounds to me" part confuse you as to its intent?

Tom

Yep. Really. Not Reagan, not Nixon, not even Kennedy during the Cuban Missile Crisis. I don't beleive a one of them would have used nuclear weapons except in retaliation. Now, the tricky part of that is whether circumstances would have dictated that they launch in response to an apparent first strike before all the facts were in, as in 'use it or lose it.' It sure is nice that that kind of threat has receded for at leas t the time being.

Mark Schynert

M.S. said

Why is that a bad thing? I like a President that keeps the opposition off balance. That means they won't press things because they won't know when we'll bite back. The Russians said the same thing about Reagan... he scared the s*it out of them.

Mark,

We all know none of them actually did it, so you're safe there, but I believe that all of the above considered pre-emptive nuclear strikes at some time in their respective tenures.

Scott G. Welch

Awww come on Bill... You know you break my heart each time you say that to me!

You're kidding, right?

Freedom of speech. Freedom of religion. Representative democracy. Those don't count as promoting a culture?

Then there are the industrial subsidies the government continues. Steel industry...industrial agriculture...

---Scott

Well......Absent the belief in the minds of a country's detractors that they would, indeed, resort to the use of nuclear weapons if necessary, they're not much of a deterrent, are they?

Regardong the possibility of misinterpreted actions resulting in an erroneous "retaliatory" launch, it's pretty remote but the slight (very slight) possibility is always there. It would be nice if we lived in a perfect world but we don't and we never will.

"The world would be a much simpler place if every one could pick and choose their obligations, but we can't and we shouldn't." Major Charles W. Whittlesey

One billion Chicoms beg to differ. They're not developing a space presence and rapid deployment capability as an homage to Detente and Glasnost.

Keep your powder dry men.

WmB

To reply, get the HECK out of there snipped-for-privacy@earthlink.net

Don't get it, eh? Reagan never scared me--pissed me off, made me laugh, made me shake my head, but never scared me. If he scared the Soviets, more bad to them. That's not part of the calculation, since I didn't care then and don't particularly care now what happens to foreign totalitarian regimes. OTOH, I'm rather fond of this country.

Bush does not scare me because he has a reactionary streak the size of the stripe on a skunk. Been there, put up with that, and in the long run, extreme attitudes in either direction in this country just bog down and change little. Sorry to rain on the idealogues' parades, but after all the sound bites and spin doctoring and attempts to slant public opinion, the country keeps going all moderate on them. We can be slightly conservative for a few years, then we'll be a bit liberal, and the net effect is not all that profound.

Bush scares me because, on the international front, his apparent level of planning, direction and doctrine seems to be completely ad hoc, pays no attention to long-term implications, and might just endanger the very existence of this country. Talking about first use of any nuclear weapon is horribly destabilizing. I find such advocacy scary. Deal with it.

Mark Schynert

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required