I have been listening to the Audio CD of ONE SECOND AFTER by William
R. Forstchen. The premise of the book is that the United States is hit
with EMP warheads. The setting of the action is in the area of Black
Mountain, NC. Almost immediately our modern high tech society is
destroyed. I am on disc 7 or thirteen right now. The story asks some
very enticing questions about our modern society. We are hanging by a
thin thread and the fictional events in this story may not be too far
fetched. It may be fiction but the possibility of it happening should
scare the hell out of all of us. I doubt if our leadership is any
better prepared to handle the situation than the fictitious leaders in
the story.
DL
DL- as my main hobby is monitoring signals, I know
what you are speaking of. I jotted down the name
of the author. I take it....it's a good read/listen?
Apparently it struck a chord with you to post about
it in here.
Many people (at least some in the rec.radio.
shortwave) think that it simply wouldn't/won't
be that bad. I on the other hand prepare for the
worst and expect the worst. ;-)
I have taken into consideration the effects of EMP
and when we were getting our home built, at least
my communications room, precautions were taken.
Of course questions were asked of me and I told
them "none of your business"... a couple of the fellas
( I think) knew what it was about.
There is nothing more I could have done, I won't go
into detail here, but it was taken seriously.
I would take into consideration a possible EMP
effect in any of your radios/comm. equipment,
be it in your home or in your BOB.
I've found that on this subject there are only
two sides, the ones that believe it will happen
and what the consequences are and the ones
(the majority IMO) that think because they say
it won't happen....that it won't happen. ;-) Follow
me?
Note that Enola Gay had no trouble flying home. Possibly my father
gave them a ride back from the plane to ops after they landed, it was
a solo flight and a VERY shocked and silent crew.
I can't write too much for several reasons but disconnected, unpowered
equipment isn't very susceptible. Got spares?
jsw
I might.
I've seen, read and heard a lot about EMP and it's practical effects.
What I meant was why do you think that this author has come up with his
scenario but that our government hasn't?
I don't know what precautions have been taken but I've seen two DOD studies
and the ramifications of an EMP event are well understood.
The consensus seemed to be that anyone in a large urban center would be in
real trouble.
Getting the military out to keep order and distribute supplies was the only
workable solution and from what I saw, you have to be pretty loose in your
definition of "workable".
I don't have any inside info but I've seen enough to know that one of
the reasons many things the military buys seem needlessly expensive is
that they require a lot of electronics to be more robust and/or
shielded to protect them from EMP.
Okay, I believe the Enola Gay was equipped with vacuum tube electronics.
Vacuum tubes are much more forgiving of EMP's.
In fact when the U.S. finally got their hands on one of Russia's MIG
fighters, they were surprised to find vacuum tube electronics, even though
transistors were quickly replacing the old technology.
Turns out the Russians weren't 'outdated', but just protecting their
fighters from a possible nuclear war.
Note that Enola Gay had no trouble flying home. Possibly my father
gave them a ride back from the plane to ops after they landed, it was
a solo flight and a VERY shocked and silent crew.
I can't write too much for several reasons but disconnected, unpowered
equipment isn't very susceptible. Got spares?
jsw
If an event like that in the book should happen I think the scenario
depicted in the CD audio/Book are probably very realistic. I remember
as a kid in the 50s/60/s when nuclear war was a real possibility Civil
Defense fallout shelters stocked with food and water for a week or two
(depending on population numbers) were scattered throughout most
cities and towns. That is no longer the case. With a total collapse of
the ELECTRIC GRID, think of the Northeast Blackout of 2005(?) but not
repairable for several months and what kind of chaos would there be?
I take several prescription medications. I keep a three month supply
on hand but IF I ran out of those medications I would not survive for
more than a few weeks. One thing pointed out in OSA (One Second After)
is how vulnerable the elderly and those with certain medical
conditions are. Insulin dependent diabetics, those with pacemakers,
dialysis patients and others would die in a few days without the
support structure provided by the Electric Grid. Starvation becomes a
concern after just a few weeks. If the event takes place during the
heat of the summer any food item that requires refrigeration must be
consumed immediately.
I grew up on a farm. Back then FACTORY farms were NOT the norm. The
farms were smaller and just about every farmer raised chickens, milked
a few cows, had a few hogs and several head of beef cattle. Now most
of the farms are huge and instead of raising a variety of crops and
animals they concentrate on one type of operation. Even farmers depend
on the local grocery stores for food. Large dairy farms may milk
hundreds or thousands of cows daily. However they do not raise their
own hay and grain to feed those cattle. They truck in feedstock from
as far as hundreds of miles away. The calves of beef breeding herds
are taken off of grass and sent to feedlots several hundred miles away
to be fattened up to slaughter weight. The same goes for chickens and
hogs. Modern agriculture is dependent on MODERN transportation.
We have a population of over 300 Million here in the United States. A
nation wide disaster like that depicted in OSA would reduce the
population to about half that within ONE year. Don't think it could
happen? Think back several years to Hurricane Katrina. Multiply that
disaster by a factor of about 1,000 and you have the scenario laid out
in OSA.
This book has scared the living shit out of me. Right now all of our
attention is focused on Obama's HEALTH CARE. Maybe we need to pay more
attention to our preparedness for a disaster like that in OSA. North
Korea and Iran and others do have or will soon have the capability to
mount an attack like that portrayed in OSA. I hope it never happens
and it probably will not, but just in case! We all need to do some
planning.
I hope some Hollywood visionary makes a movie on OSA that follows the
story line exactly. The movie THE CHINA SYNDROME stopped the expansion
of the Nuclear power industry in its tracks. Maybe a movie based on
ONE SECOND AFTER would wake up enough people in the country to events
that COULD happen and we might make the decisions necessary for
survival.
DL
Let the Record show that Jim Wilkins on or about
Sat, 22 Aug 2009 06:13:47 -0700 (PDT) did write/type or cause to
appear >> TwoGuns wrote:
Note as well, that the Enola Gay had no transistorized equipment.
-
pyotr filipivich
We will drink no whiskey before its nine.
It's eight fifty eight. Close enough!
Let the Record show that Bushcraftgregg on or
about Sat, 22 Aug 2009 03:03:16 -0700 (PDT) did write/type or cause to
appear in rec.crafts.metalworking the following:
Is more than just your comm gear. It is everything else which is
dependent on transistorized controllers. Electronic Fuel Injection?
Smart Electric Meters? Computerized controls for oil or natural gas
pipelines? For water utilities? No power, no pumps; no pumps, no
water.
How "soft" those targets are, is hard to say. I'm inclined to
them being both harder and softer than expected. Inevitably, the toys
will prove the most robust, and the essential services will go out
with the first poof.
_One Second After_ is a deliberate thing,. Then there is the
Carrington Event effect. Last Big One occurred in 1859, a solar storm
which ejected quite a bit of material. (a "lessor" one in 1989 took
out the Quebec grid.) Caused very spectacular Auroras - visible in
Cuba, which normally is way too far south. Other fun effect - "Even
when telegraphers disconnected the batteries powering the lines,
aurora-induced electric currents in the wires still allowed messages
to be transmitted." (I had to go look this back up -- that line just
stuck. But this will mean "Free electricity for everyone!")
Fortunately, that all occurred before the introduction of cross
country power girds. Were such an event to occur now, it is possible
to fry the grid across the eastern quarter of the continent- and there
simply are not enough of the critical components available to restore
power before backup systems run out.
The crucial component is a fancy form of transformer. The induced
current from a Carrington event would melt them. While most Utilities
may have one or two spares on hand, they are usually custom built,
with the lead time for replacement being up to a year. Assuming the
factory has power, that delivery can be done without local power. Etc,
etc.
-
pyotr filipivich
We will drink no whiskey before its nine.
It's eight fifty eight. Close enough!
"Additionally as a security officer, I carry a gun to protect
government officials but my life isn't worth protecting at home
in their eyes." Dick Anthony Heller
I've wondered what would happen if our technological infrastructure would be
hit. It is
on my buy list. Working on Apache atm.
Apache: Inside the Cockpit of the World's Most Deadly Fighting Machine
(Hardcover)
by Ed Macy (Author) Saw a review on on in Air & Space magazine.
Wes
--
"Additionally as a security officer, I carry a gun to protect
government officials but my life isn't worth protecting at home
in their eyes." Dick Anthony Heller
I'm going to listen to it because I like apocalyptic fiction. I have
to admit that the author picked an outstanding place for survival.
Black Mountain is near (but not too close to Asheville.) It's
relatively remote, mountain country and sparsely populated (7,511
people, 3,340 households, and 2,027 families.) The population density
is 1,165.7 people per square mile. If you don't come up I-40, you
don't get there by car and it's rough country for walking.
I'd like to compare what is actually there with what the author says
is there to see if he got that part right.
Someone has already made a decent mini-series that starts out with an EMP
attack.
The focus, however, was nuclear winter.
I can't imagine any first strike by the US or anyone being land based but
such a plan would certainly include numerous large weapons specifically
designed to generate huge EM pulses. I say I can't imagine a land based
first strike because you wouldn't want to give an opponent a chance to
respond and land based missiles have to travel a long way and they are
detectable.
An American SSBN or six, on the other hand, could sneak right up to within a
couple of minutes range of just about anyone in the world and in two minutes
an enemy couldn't even pull their finger out. Depending on their load out
and configuration, six boomers could deliver 384 independently targeted
nukes all at once, with precision, and without any real warning.
That's what you'd do if it came down to it.
No Wes, it isn't.
It's something to think about though.
One of the questions people who try and position themselves to survive a
nuclear exchane never seem to ask is the obvious one.
Why would you want to?
I posted the original comments. I used to drive a truck all over the
US and Canada. I have made quite a few trips across I-40 and the area
where the story is set. From what I remember of the area the author
was spot on in the geography. I don't want to give any of the story
away in case some want to read or listen to it but one major MORAL in
the story is that survival is not only self reliance.
I finished listening to the CD Audio this afternoon and enjoyed it
immensely. I will read the book when the local library gets it in
also. Time well spent IMHO.
DL
This does not belong in rec.crafts.metalworking, so I've set
followups to alt.survival only. And I won't be reading it there.
Note that the Enola Gay did not have a single transistor or IC
on the whole aircraft. They had not been invented at that time. And
solid state circuitry (transistors and ICs) are *much* more vulnerable
to the voltage and current spikes induced by EMP. Tubes are amazingly
forgiving for such things.
This is why the Soviet military aircraft would have done better
than our own aircraft during the Cold War.
[ ... ]
Disconnected is the most important part of that -- and ideally
in a metal enclosure acting as a shield. But these days, how much of
our power grid is controlled by solid state devices -- and those are
*very* vulnerable to EMP. So what you have would still work only as
long as you could keep batteries charged to run them -- and the radio
stations would almost certainly be down anyway. Write off the internet,
at least until everything switches over to fiber optics, and the machine
rooms are all properly shielded.
Enjoy,
DoN.
PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.