Yes. Services would be taxed the same as any other purchase.
No, you get a pass there, money spent out of the country isn't taxed. There's no way to require foreign countries to collect the tax. But then you aren't drawing on US services while in another country either.
That expense would be gone. Boo Hoo, lawyers will have to find honest work.
A sales tax by its very nature is egalitarian. It doesn't care who you are, who you know, what you make, or how you make it. It only cares what you spend. Spend money, pay the tax. Don't spend the money, don't pay tax, but don't get any benefit from it either. Your choice.
Gary
Didn't find your answer? Ask the community — no account required.
G
Gary Coffman
Yes. The complaint you hear against this is that it would reduce liquidity, ie volatility of the market. I don't see that as a bad thing. Both investors and companies would have to plan for the long term, rather than just the next quarter. I see that as an unmitigated good for the long term health of the economy, businesses, and jobs.
Gary
J
jim rozen
Gary I cannot bite my tongue any longer here, I'm sorry. But the above statement is *so* outrageous I have to say something.
Tax laws are written for, and by, corporations, to benefit them. This is how politics works in the US - the money runs the political, not the other way 'round. If you really, *truly* think you can create a workable sales tax system whereby large corporations don't engineer in their own exemptions/exceptions/breaks that mimic the existing tax structure, I would have to say that you are a total, helpless, romantic.
This is how it would play out in the real world:
Income tax would be eliminated. National universal sales tax would be installed in its place. Wealthy citizens and large corporations would instantly have their own private back door installed.
The middle and lower class peasants will then wind up paying more tax than before.
Jim
================================================== please reply to: JRR(zero) at yktvmv (dot) vnet (dot) ibm (dot) com ==================================================
J
jim rozen
Hmm. But the present tax code had been around for many many years. Was there something that one could point to that has happened recently with it, that sparked off the huge batch of outsourcing that's gone on recently the past couple of years?
Jim
================================================== please reply to: JRR(zero) at yktvmv (dot) vnet (dot) ibm (dot) com ==================================================
E
Ed Huntress
engineering,
If the idea is so good, why don't we have it now? Who is it who's conspiring against this logical system of yours and hiding from us how wonderful it would be?
Ed Huntress
E
Ed Huntress
If we're all incorporated, then who will pay all the taxes? Soldiers?
Ed Huntress
E
Ed Huntress
First, the amount isn't huge. Coming up with reliable numbers isn't possible right now, and may never be, but they're a very small percentage of our economy and of our workforce.
That's in the aggregate. Like most trade issues, the picture flip-flops if you're one of the "displacements" whose job has been offshored.
In manufacturing industries, it relates closely to the flows of capital. When it's easy to invest in a low-wage country that has a pool of reasonably educated workers, like China, it can happen fast. That's the situation now. It wouldn't have happened if China hadn't opened its doors to foreign capital.
The IT offshoring is related more to technology advances and the result of India, particularly, working to build its pool of well-educated technology workers.
So there are different reasons.
As for Gary's point about VATs, it's more a philosophical point than a real one, but it is true that a VAT has a small effect equivalent to a tariff. It raises prices for consumers, who wind up paying for their own social costs through the VAT. The foreign producers don't pay it. What can happen, to some degree, is that it can discourage the purchase of imported goods because the price differential between imported- and domestically-produced goods is reduced. But make no mistake, it's the consumers who pay it. They effectively pay their own tariffs each time they buy something, foreign or domestic, if they have a VAT. That's what they do in Europe, and it's a large part of the reason their aggregate unemployment is high and their per-capita incomes are generally lower than ours.
VATs are a multi-edged sword. To help keep it all clear, just remember that there is no free lunch.
Ed Huntress
G
Gary Coffman
The politicians, of course. They don't want you to be reminded of how much they are costing you each time you make a purchase.
Gary
E
Ed Huntress
Of course. The ultimate conspiracy.
Could it possibly be that your idea is a crock of baloney?
Ed Huntress
G
Gary Coffman
The consumer pays *every* tax, either directly at point of sale, or indirectly through higher prices. Don't be fooled into thinking you can get corporations to pay, they're just indirect tax collectors. The end consumer always pays, no matter what tax system you have.
Europe's problem is not the VAT, it is the VAT *on top of every other tax* that they levy. In other words, their taxes are higher in general than ours. The particular forms those taxes take is secondary to that single over- whelming factor.
What I've been touting is a retail sales tax as a *replacement* for all other forms of taxation. That's *completely different* from what they have in Europe. So dragging the European VAT into the discussion is a total red herring.
Gary
E
Ed Huntress
domestically-produced
The point all of these tax-revolution enthusiasms miss, Gary, is that the tax structure, more than the overall level of taxes, drives the way an economy works. If you tax consumption, you dampen consumption. It doesn't matter if the consumer makes out the same either way. What matters is how the taxes relate to rates of return on investments; how they influence the price of one use of money versus another; and so on.
Take them one at a time, and see what would happen. First, how would a new company make an initial offering of its stock if you slap a 23% tax on top of the sale? Who would buy a new stock?
There are a few hundred more such questions, but we can start with this one. What would happen?
Ed Huntress
G
Glenn Ashmore
Well, you have got yourself sold on something based on the figments of someone's imagination and I can see that no amount of reality will change your mind.
I am just glad that there are a few reasonably intelligent advisors in DC with at least a tenuous grip on reality even though none seem to be in the present administration.
G
Glenn Ashmore
OK, what do you think will happen?
So we tack a 23% tax on every stock transaction. Now what will happen to the stock market? At least there will be fewer day traders.
When there is an alternative to services or any other purchase, the consumer will tend to ballance the cost against the benifit. Back in
1955 when the minimum wage broke $1/hour 90% of the maids and yardmen in the country lost their jobs. This distroyed a relatively vibrant black ecconomic society and set the stage for 40 years of welfare debaccle.
Without the 23% penalty you placed on domestic investments that is going to send ALL the capital investment offshore. If you think outsourcing is a problem now, just wait.
Lawyers were placed on earth by God as punishment for that apple incident. As long as there are tax laws there will be tax lawyers getting paid by those who can afford them to figure ways not to pay taxes.
If the economy is not "egalitarian" why should the tax structure be? And I doubt you would be in favor of an egalitarian economy.
J
jim rozen
Right. But saying "our present tax structure is responsible for sending jobs overseas, we can fix that with XYZ" doesn't make sense - if the *real* reason for the jobs that are being 'offshored' really lies somewhere else.
So I would not point to this as a reason to change from our present type of taxation, to the XYZ, or the GC type, either! :)
Jim
================================================== please reply to: JRR(zero) at yktvmv (dot) vnet (dot) ibm (dot) com ==================================================
E
Ed Huntress
Just how simple an answer are you looking for? And how much destruction of the US economy will you tolerate in order to reduce offshoring?
You have to be able to answer those two questions, Jim. And they're interconnected.
Ed Huntress
J
jim rozen
Hmm. I would suggest that whatever changes made in the tax code be very incremental. Small to start.
I find it hard to believe that the entire US economy is dependent on overseas job flight. If it is, then the process won't stop until all the jobs are gone, and there are no consumers left to purchase.
Again, I would try to implement some kind of plan to make it incrementally less attractive (read: more expensive) for companies to send jobs overseas. Sure the labor rate is 1/20 but there is some cost of bringing the entire operation offshore. Just make it known that the government will reward those who keep jobs here, and apply the stick to those who jump on the bandwagon.
Right now companies *have* to take advantage of the labor break, or they're going to be run over by those who do. Just make it a bit tougher for them to get trampled.
Jim
================================================== please reply to: JRR(zero) at yktvmv (dot) vnet (dot) ibm (dot) com ==================================================
J
jim rozen
And they *will* be employed by the folks who have the most money. The more the money, the better the hired gun. You might say, abolish lawyers but that's only part of the issue.
Right now the tax code is written by the corporations, for their benefit. The rate at which lawyers shuffle back and forth between private and public sector is really amazing.
Really, in most cases, the regulations are being drafted by the regulat*ed*.
Jim
================================================== please reply to: JRR(zero) at yktvmv (dot) vnet (dot) ibm (dot) com ==================================================
G
Gary Coffman
Corporations would love a flat sales tax. They don't pay it, they just collect it. It removes property taxes, inventory taxes, payroll taxes, income taxes, etc, etc from their window of concern, so they can lay off a bunch of tax accountants and lawyers. They can make business decisions based on business consequences intead of worrying about what tax consequence it might have. It also places an effectively automatic tariff on all imported goods, giving domestic corporations a boost in sales. What's not to like?
The middle class comes off Ok too. I'm middle class, and I currently pay more than 50% of my gross income as taxes of one sort or another. Dropping that to 23% of what I spend seems like a good deal to me.
Wealthy individuals may not like it very much, because it allows them no way to dodge paying their fair share of taxes. But it is a fair tax, much simpler than the current system, a lower rate than the current system, and doesn't penalize the accumulation of wealth. I think they'll adapt.
Now drug dealers, numbers runners, racketeers, and the like won't like it. They don't pay taxes on their earnings now, but under the new system, they will have to pay taxes on everything they spend of their ill gotten gains. Tough luck for the crooks.
Illegals won't like it. They work off the books now, so they don't pay taxes. But they'll have to pay the new sales tax on everything they buy. Maybe they'll decide to go back home.
Tax lawyers, accountants, and IRS employees won't like it either, because it'll put them out of work. But I can live with that.
The main group that won't like it, however, are politicians and government bureaucrats. It puts the cost of what they're doing right out in front of the taxpayers every time they purchase anything. That's going to make people angry and cause them to call for government reforms to reduce wasteful and frivolous government spending, and to make every department of government more frugal with the taxpayer's dollars. I think that would be a very good thing, but they won't.
Gary
E
Ed Huntress
Their sales would go to hell. Otherwise, they'd love it.
No you don't.
So, if you were right, and your taxes were cut in half, how would the other half be made up?
What percentage of their income do you think goes to consumption in the US?
Ed Huntress
J
jim rozen
Nope, they'll use their present political power, to weasel an exception or exemption from your 'universal' sales tax. This is how it works in the real world!
Actually I'm starting to like this more and more - but I'm positive that it will never come to pass, for the reason I gave up at the top, and more importantly, for the reason you gave at the end!
Jim
================================================== please reply to: JRR(zero) at yktvmv (dot) vnet (dot) ibm (dot) com ==================================================
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required
Report Content
You are reporting this content to the moderators. They will look at it
ASAP.