OT - Jobs Lost

Feb 13, 2004 282 Replies

If you believe that, please say so, and we can discuss it. It isn't true.

I think you know what the facts are. You can grow your economy out of it, or you can lower standards of living (as by what we're doing right now, letting the dollar fall on world currency markets) in order to increase employment.

Those are the choices. What you can't do is isolate parts of your economy from the market, without causing a lot of pain.

Ed Huntress

I don't think the entire economy depends on job flight to keep working. So therefore I don't think all the jobs will be gone someday.

I thought you were saying that the economy *does* depend on jobs going overseas though, and would collapse if that were impeded.

The government has regulated business in the past. It will continue to do so in various areas. It seems to me that regulation of how companies do business in the US could indeed address how they employ foreign workers.

Jim

================================================== please reply to: JRR(zero) at yktvmv (dot) vnet (dot) ibm (dot) com ==================================================

The way it works now, every segment of the economy is interconnected, and every foreign trade relationship we have impinges on our whole economy. If you take offshoring out of the picture you take some large US corporations out of the globally competitive picture. Doing it unilaterally is a prescription for corporate bankrupcies.

But that wouldn't cause our economy to collapse, nor will "all" jobs leave the US for foreign countries no matter what happens. The process is self-limiting. If our economy really suffers overall, the much-maligned monatarists' solution kicks in, and the value of our currency drops until the hemhorraging stops. That is, assuming that the decline in our economy doesn't result in a worldwide decline, which is possible. If that happens, we could lose large numbers of jobs, but they wouldn't be going overseas. They'd just disappear into a depression.

Adjustments can be a very painful process for the economy, and even more so for many individuals who find themselves in the "displacement" category. It's especially tough now because we're being whip-sawed by the size and velocity of displacements that we're experiencing. But all jobs aren't going to leave, even though our economy is going to remain very sensitive to any anti-competitive protections we try to enforce. What we need, IMO, is not protections, but a continued loosening of currency restraints and a Manhatten-sized project to boost education.

If that isn't enough, a modest VAT could help. Gary's VAT solution is no solution to taxation in general, but we're the only one of our major trading partners who doesn't do some of their taxing by means of a VAT, and it does put us at a disadvantage.

Not collapse, but suffer. If you're interested in GDP, you get the best figures by loosening trade restraints, including offshoring. That's the economy in the aggregate, which is what the head of the President's Council of Economic Advisors was talking about a couple of weeks ago.

If your economy isn't growing fast enough to replace those jobs, it really hurts, and you don't get the rise in GDP that you expect. It could even go down although it hasn't. Our GDP is growing, albeit without much energy.

If the velocity is so high that *no* reasonable rate of growth will replace those jobs, then you have to take other measures, like playing real hardball with your currency and employing VATs. It could happen. It hasn't happened yet.

That's the kind of protectionism that will provoke retaliation. You're into the realm of unknown and unintended consequences.

Currency and VATs are fairly immune to retaliation.

So, you're now saying to forget everything you've been claiming about how escalating tax rates don't matter, aren't penalties, and don't affect how people behave. You've got religion now and believe that taxes do matter, and do have effects on the behavior of the people being taxed. Well, that's a start anyway.

Someone who saw good long term prospects for the company. Day traders who depend on playing point or two fluctuations based on rumors or emotional market swings would be out of business, of course. Good riddance. "Technical" traders who follow charts instead of understanding a company's business would be out too. Both are just gamblers, playing hunches or "systems". But investors looking for long term growth would still buy the most promising companies' stocks.

Companies going nowhere, or in actual decline, wouldn't find many buyers, of course, but a *new* company, one with bright prospects, well that would be the long term growth investor's meat and potatoes. Would you have paid a 23% premium to get in on Xerox's IPO? Or Polaroid? Microsoft?

That's every investor's dream, to get in on the ground floor of the hot new thing. The stock that's going to show dramatic upward movement during the company's first few years of business. That's where fortunes are made.

Nobody is going to get rich buying GM or Con Ed or Firestone. They're stodgy old companies who show very little year to year growth. A 23% sales tax would *force* investors to look for the companies with promise of explosive growth. Mostly, that'll be IPOs, not an old regulated utility or tired rust belt company with declining market share.

Gary

No, they'll all be incorporated too. The state will wither away. Any necessary public functions will be taken over by private enterprise. People will hire Joe's police force and Bill's fire company to protect their property, Sam's water company to deliver water to them, Mike's sanitation to haul off their garbage, etc.

Soldiers will form free companies, and hire out to the highest bidder, ie Big Al's army will fight for you, if you pay them enough. Or if you aren't that serious about the war, then you can get Little Moe's guys for a good deal less money.

Gary

I'm most interested to see this topic discussed here as I've only heard it mentioned before some years ago by a chap named Lester Thurow(sp) of MIT who exponded upon it from time to time on a TV business program IIRC. I've discussed it with a few but no-one seems to get very interested.

Exactly - am important point that some miss.

I've also been of the opinion for years that a consumption tax replacing income and even business taxes would be hugely benificial. I've not followed this thread from the start but, if it hasn't been mentioned, one large benefit would be the elimination of hords of tax accountants, lawyers and their support infastructure and associated cost to society, both on the consumer/business side plus the government. Just the time & aggrivation saved by individual's by not having to prepare tax forms would furthermore be immense.

One downside would be that low income earners, who now pay little or no taxes, would be at a monetary disadvantage. This however could be compensated for by giving each adult (and child) a certain amount each month to make up the difference (by auto deposit into bank accounts perhaps, or some such mechanism).

The consumption tax could also be made "progressive" if desired (rich pay a higher fraction than poor) by having a higher consumption tax on "luxury" goods.

I'd vote for such a scheme in a second but I doubt it would ever happen as so much political control would be lost and the lobbying against it (by those whose services would no longer be required to support the existing system) would be fierce.

Laurie Forbes

Have to agree here - it would not make sense to tax investment transactions.

It would not be necessary to have the same tax rate on every commodity or service. Groceries or perscription drugs, for example, may also have a zero tax rate. Luxury goods could have a higher rate.

I'm not sure how you would handle foreign tourist spending however - maybe an exemption or rebate scheme?

Laurie Forbes

Oh, they have a LOT of effect on how people behave. If you want to see how big an effect it can have, yank the $3.9 billion US cotton subsidy, pull the other tax breaks off of the cotton-producing and textile industries, and then slap a 23% sales tax on cotton goods, and watch how fast you've just changed consumer behavior.

But the rich aren't going to stop trying to get richer because they've been bumped into a marginally higher tax bracket. It isn't going to make them try to be poorer, for chrissake.

That's what I said.

BZZZT!. You missed it. They'd buy established stocks in preference to stocks of new companies, because (if I understand your plan correctly) there would be no tax on the sales of existing stocks.

Big, established companies would love your plan. You'd destroy any chance they would acquire new competitors.

Only if I knew it was going to be Xerox, or Polaroid, or Microsoft. Unless you knew if for sure, only an idiot would buy stock in a company that had to overcome a 23% tax burden on the stock price alone, before it would return anything at all. He'd buy an established stock.

Well, there's a good business for you. You can tell people which companies are going to be hugely successful, so they can ignore the rest. Which new companies would you buy today, for example, if they were saddled with a 23% tax due on purchase?

Get out that old crystal ball. Not only do you have to pick winners, you have to pick big-time winners who will outperform established stocks by 23% over the short haul. Bye, bye, IPO's. Hello, IBM.

Oh my God. Gary, you have lost it.

OK, time to get serious. There are several reasons for the state to run certain enterprises. One is the theory of natural monopoly and redundant plant, which I assume you've studied in economics, or you should have. It's the reason you don't want Sam's water company to compete with another water plant in the same geographical area. With two water companies competing, you will pay more for water. With three competing, you'll pay more still. The more competition you have the higher will be your prices. That's the result of redundant plant and diseconomy of scale -- the bases of natural monopoly.

You'll want to brush up on it so you remember why you want only one water company, and, if it's private, why you want to regulate the hell out of it. Failing to observe the principles was the direct cause of the Northeast power blackout last year, and it was part of the screwup that led to the California electricity crisis. The privatizers got their wacky little hands into each, and both did a half-assed job of it.

Another major reason is related, and it became apparent after 9/11. That is, a non-competing private enterprise, such as the security at US airports before it was re-federalized, follows normal business incentives and, without competition, will provide the cheapest, lowest-performing service it can get away with. Thus, minimum-wage, undertrained morons who lasted an average of 6 months on the job defending your life and the security of our airspace.

Privatization of natural monopolies usually is a loser, because the incentives for private enterprise are in all the wrong places for a non-competing business or service. If you try to artificially create competition where it doesn't belong, where you wind up eating the costs of duplicative plant and distribution or giving a free ride to some enterprise that has its incentives to perform stripped away because it's detached from either production or the final distribution of the service, they'll steal you blind.

Privatization makes sense where you have real competition and where competition doesn't adversely affect economies of scale, and, most particularly, where it doesn't require either building redundant plant, or reducing distribution to the status of a common carrier, with no responsibility for the overall production and delivery of the service. If you do it in the wrong places you just get ripped off and the service gets screwed up. Just ask the people from California or northern New York state.

Ed Huntress

Another L. Neil Smith fan!!

Gunner

"To be civilized is to restrain the ability to commit mayhem. To be incapable of committing mayhem is not the mark of the civilized, merely the domesticated." - Trefor Thomas

Would this be one of the "pains" you refer to?

A car company can move its factories to Mexico and it's a free market.

A toy company can outsource to a Chinese subcontractor and it's a free market.

A major bank can incorporate in Bermuda to avoid taxes and it's a free market.

We can buy HP Printers made in Mexico.

We can buy shirts made in Bangladesh.

We can purchase almost anything we want from many different countries.

BUT, heaven help the elderly who dare to buy their prescription drugs from a Canadian (Or Mexican) pharmacy. That's called un-American!

Never happen. You need to have the federal goverment in there to run the school system, like gunner says.

Jim

================================================== please reply to: JRR(zero) at yktvmv (dot) vnet (dot) ibm (dot) com ==================================================

The thing that bothers me is a sneaking suspicion that a) companies did just fine before overseas manufacture existed, and b) they're using the opportunity to simply boost profits. I doubt anybody would go bankrupt - don't european companies get regulated by their govenments? The entire thing about US companies sending jobs overseas just *looks* like gouging.

This is a real concern. Wouldn't it be better to try to damp down the 'velocity' of the displacments a bit, rather than let them build up and cause a big crisis, all at once?

We had ww2 to boost us out of the depression, and the space program in the 60s to boost the economy then. But there's been nothing like those to galvanize the country. I think you're right, maybe gunner's 'federal education program' could do this!

And the jobless rate is still pretty high, and the consumer confidence is pretty low. Those are bad signs; the wizard econcomists may believe all the stuff that's being spouted, but the folks with the paychecks certainly don't.

Yet...

I can see a tarriff on imported goods as being labeled protectionist. But writing rules about how US companies sent jobs overseas? I can sure see the US companies screaming bloody murder about it. But other countries?

Don't forget, I'm not talking about *stopping* the problem, just slowing it down a bit - damping out the rate at which the changes happen, to spread them out over five years or so.

Jim

================================================== please reply to: JRR(zero) at yktvmv (dot) vnet (dot) ibm (dot) com ==================================================

That's an odd situation, in the most heavily regulated manufacturing industry. What's going on there is that the whole world regulates drug prices...except for us. So we're the country in which the drug companies recover practically all of their development costs.

It won't last much longer, IMO. It's an odd-ball of a market.

Ed Huntress

Gee! Most big cities are already at this point. The free companies are called "gangs". There are limits to free enterprise and all other forms of government.

Ed Patters>Soldiers will form free companies, and hire out to the highest bidder,

What gave you that idea? Sales tax would be charged on anything you buy.

Gary

I thought you said it would only be charged on *new* things that you buy? I could swear you said that. Or maybe one of the other VAT people said it.

In any case, are you saying it would apply to *all* stock sales, new or old? That ought to kill the *entire* US stock market in a hurry. It will do wonders for London and Tokyo, however.

Ed Huntress

Of course, that's the reason. By purchasing manufactured goods from countries where they can be made at much lower cost, the company saves money, thus improving their bottom line. At the same time, they can sell their end products at a lower price, so the consumer benefits. These effects help the economy grow, thus leading to the creation of new jobs. The manufacturer in the low cost country is employing people and making money, too, so, in fact, everybody wins. :-)

...except those individuals who would have manufactured the goods if they hadn't been available from abroad. They're out of a job, and, to them, it's not much consolation to know that the country as a whole is better off this way, or that, in total, jobs are gained, not lost.

This is the big challenge, I guess. Regulating the changes so that the positive effects can be gained, while softening the blow to the people who will be displaced. If the transition takes time, it may be possible for at least some affected companies to realign themselves, producing more marketable goods, and for employees to retrain. Easy it is not.

-tih

Well, Ed's rule is that labor in china costs about 1/20th of what it costs in the US.

Now I'm gonna be generous here, and say that labor is only about half of the cost of an item's manufacture. (down to

1/10)

Then I'm gonna be generous again, and say that the company has more cost transporting the goods from overseas. So that would be maybe a factor of two. (now 1/5)

And then I'm gonna say that they *deserve* more profit, like another factor of two. (here it's 1/2.5)

So are things really 2.5 times cheaper than they were before all this outsourcing???? Don't think so!

Jim

================================================== please reply to: JRR(zero) at yktvmv (dot) vnet (dot) ibm (dot) com ==================================================

Wrong Jim..Ive never said the government needs to run the schools. Only that they should set some educational standards.

Think of Underwriters Labs. They test, they set standards, but they dont write laws or enforce them.

If your product doesnt pass their standards, no UL sticker.

Shrug

Gunner

"To be civilized is to restrain the ability to commit mayhem. To be incapable of committing mayhem is not the mark of the civilized, merely the domesticated." - Trefor Thomas

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required