Once again, an "authoritative" definition is meaningless in the context here. Legally, the old Veeday kits were "scale models"....but I am willing to bet that very few of "us" (i.e. average modelers, with average or high standards), considered Veeday products as "accurate scale miniatures".
We should endeavor to expect things to live up to our standards, not simply meet the minimal "authoritative" definition. Hormel Canned Tamales might "legally" be considered TexMex cuisine...but no serious person would ever consider them to be authentic (accurate). Canned beans have to meet the "authoritative" standard of having no more than x% of rat poop in them...but that does not mean we should not expect better.
Once again, you fall back on *my* point about the act of building the model. Even if one builds using minimum personal standards, there is still the conscious act of trying to meet a standard; and not just accepting what comes "out-of-the-box". One actually tries to glue the correct pieces together. If they are going to paint the model, and are unsure as to what color(s) to use, they will actually do some research, even if it is minimal. They may just ask another modeler. But they are seeking the *right* answer. It seems that even these most limited of standards, get ignored, when dealing with "already completed" miniatures. I am simply asking why....
Yes...I have seen it. And just as in the photograph, the head is oversized. The feet are slightly oversized (length-wise....their height is okay...i.e. no "Mickey Mouse" feet, as common in others). The clothing, as mentioned earlier, has many scale problems. The equipage is light on detail, with a lot missing, but easily correctable.
No...not everyone who ever has built a model...but those of us who are frequent contributors to this small group, and who have demonstrated that they have the high standards I mentioned. Consider us a "family"...I do. When talking amongst ourselves, using the pronoun "we" is not incorrect, nor does it have to refer to those outside the "family". I would suspect that there is not a single "regular" here who does *not* have high standards. (higher than the average non-modeler)