Photo Etch - Here to Stay?

Seems more often than not, that kits include PE as standard equipment, so to speak. With us boomers with less than perfect fingers and hands, its getting to be a bit frustrating to find a subject you want to build but find that key parts are PE. I have to pass on those kits.

Is the hobby just going through a phase with this detail feature? They used to be only an aftermarket option, not a required part of a kit.

Will those who just want to build be relegated to old Revell repops?

Not every modeler is going for a museum piece.

Craig

Reply to
crw59
Loading thread data ...

equipment,

hands,

Personally, I think they are here to stay. In the beginning the PE was used to enhance a kit or perhaps convert it to a different variant. Today's super-comprehensive sets try to replace all parts that should or shouldn't be PE.

Same deal with the kits. When the manufacturers toss in a small PE fret, it allows them to bump the price up. I wouldn't worry though, there are still going to be plenty of kits that are all plastic without having to find ancient repops.

Reply to
rgronovius

Yes - I think etched parts are going to become a fact of life in a quality kit (particularly in the larger scales), if only because the aftermarket for them is so strong. And in some cases they just plain make sense - I know a lot of folk hate Trumpeters etched hinges, but I think they are a stroke of genius - durable and functional. And that's something I want in a kit - the ability to handle it once it's finished without fear of things popping off.

I know that I personally refuse to build an aircraft kit without etched parts these days - whether they come in the kit, or I have to buy them from Eduard. Most of the time I need to do both - the kit etch (other than structural parts - like those hinges) dosen't quite measure up to the aftermarket stuff...but I suppose that is to be expected, or there wouldn't be an aftermarket.

Reply to
Rufus

Dunno. PE in either after-market and in the kit has been around for some time. I remember the early DML German fighters had both white metal and etched frets back in the late 80s. We're also seeing more and more kits that include resin details in them now. Of course Monogram included some resin bits in a couple of their Pro Modeler sets over 10 years ago as well. With the demand for more accuracy and more detail in kits, I'd think this will be around a while.

Reply to
Bill Woodier

pe is tough for a guy with arthritis, but not every new kit i buy has it. sometimes i want to super detail, sometimes not. with the huge asortmrnt out there, i uspect you'll never run out of kits you like. i'll take them revell repops if you don't want them...and your lindbergs and matchbox.

Reply to
e

rufus, you are going to be the first climically recognized case of pe dependence. "but dr. it's just that the kit looked a little bare!"

Reply to
e

I have the same problems as you. It is not the eyes- I can always pick up more powerful reading glasses. But my arthritic finger joints are just not steady enough with the tweezers. I also find in dry weather that static charge seems to sometimes repel small pieces from tweezers.

I do not refrain from buying those kits. The really small PE detail parts I sometimes pass over, however. The bigger pieces are okay, and look nice compared to fat molded plastic.

Reply to
Don Stauffer in Minneapolis

...I want a cut if it becomes known as "Rufus Syndrome".

Reply to
Rufus

won't happen. you'll be a footnote and some dr will get the creds.

Reply to
e

PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.