Hole callouts

Jun 19, 2006 5 Replies

I've not used Hole Callouts that much, as I've not yet figured out how to customise the file that determines the format of the annotation.



However, today I needed to quickly identify the size of a hole on a drawing, so I used one. It produced a very misleading result. This was because the face on which I defined the hole had a "near side" chamfer, but in the drawing I was viewing the part from the opposite side. The hole callout still said the chamfer was "near side", when on the drawing it was really "far side".



Is this a recent bug, or is it just a limitation of the functionality that the hole callouts can't recognise which end of the hole you are looking at?



Regards, John H


I've run into several issues with hole callouts in SW2006 that I didn't have in SW2005. I have yet to report any (shame on me), but this could be part of what your seeing as well.

"Seth Renigar" wrote in news:_Dxlg.32226$ snipped-for-privacy@southeast.rr.com:

I've given up reporting issues on hole callouts. They can't be relied on to give accurate info on holes of any complexity but the very simplest. In most cases, I have to verify that it is actually giving a correct description. A lot of the time I have a simple hole, and it is correct. For the rest, I have to build a hole callout manually.

I do agree with the others that the Hole Callout is still lacking in functionality, but in this case there is a legitimate answer (all tho I don't like, and you probably won't it either)...

SW Hole Callouts follow ANSI Standards which say no Hidden Lines are to be dimensioned...therefore everything is expected to be dimensioned from the Near Side. So SW doesn't prevent you from dimensioning from the Far Side, but the callout will be the same whether you are dimensioning from the Near or Far side...so watch out.

Ken

"Tin Man" wrote

What happens if you have a hole that is counterbored on the near side and countersunk on the far side?

Regards, John H

Yeah....but I meant that the hole callout would list the countersink, even if it was on the opposite side and therefore hidden - it wouldn't comply with the ANSI standard,

John

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required