Re: S 724 is as dead as yesterday's fish

Aug 01, 2003 29 Replies

So do I, and I have been polygraphed.

The problem with a polygraph is that it is NOT a lie detector. It will accurately measure respiration, heartbeat, and skin resistance. It assumes that when a person practices deception, certain physiological parameters will change as well.

The problem is, these paremeters may or may not change, and they do not change uniformly in all people (or for that matter in the same person). The ultimate arbiter of the truthfulness or deception of a statement is the person administering the test. And different testers, when presented with the same polygraph data, provide different opinions.

This is the key word: OPINION. The results of a polygraph are an OPINION. And because of this, they are not admissible in criminal proceedings.

I'm a test engineer. The tests I design must be repeatable and reproducible in order to be useful, and I use tools to gauge the repeatability and reproducibility of my tests. A polygraph is neither repeatable nor reproducible.

Frank Rizzo, Philly's former Mayor and Police Commissioner, was an ardent supporter of polygraphs until he failed one.

FWIW, I passed mine.

Bill Sullivan

Oooh, oooh, I just gots to chime in here. Speaking of opinions and test engineers: "One test is worth a thousand expert opinions."

Doug Test engineer many, many years ago...

Me too. Now I mostly just test future engineers. ;)

-John

So you say......

Care to take a polygraph?

steve

Is passing a polygraph like passing a kidney stone?

len.

Can't be half as bad as passing a Cessna 150. Even a little bit at a time...

formatting link

tah

No, NSA.

Bill Sullivan

Government employees are NOT held to the same standard as citizens and that is a major error.

Jerry

Thanks for the nightmares...

Bob Kaplow NAR # 18L TRA # "Impeach the TRA BoD" >>> To reply, remove the TRABoD!

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required