Saving Private Lynch: the making of the myth Mark Bowden NYT Friday, June 13, 2003
BOSTON So it turns out that the feel-good story of the Iraq war, the rescue of Private Jessica Lynch, may not have the plot line of a made-for-television movie.
It seems the plucky young private may not have fought like Rambo when her unit took a wrong turn into an Iraqi ambush. She may not have been shot and stabbed in that firefight, which may or may not have happened, and it seems likely now that she was not mistreated at an Iraqi hospital. Her heroic rescuers did not fight their way up the hospital halls; indeed, the hospital staff may have been eager to hand her over, had perhaps even tried to the day before, only to be turned back by skittish American soldiers at a roadblock.
If you find this series of conditional phrases annoying, welcome to the fog of war. War is about sudden, violent change, and it is always difficult to make sense of events, either from close or from afar. What emerges from the fog is always incomplete, and often wrong.
When the rescue story broke on April 2, information came from a public briefing and from military intelligence sources, relying on field reports from soldiers and interviews with Iraqi civilians. No journalists were present when Lynch was captured or rescued. The reports contained errors and contradictions, which have now prompted allegations that the Pentagon tried to pull a fast one.
The BBC recently aired a story that claimed the Lynch story, as first reported, was part of a Pentagon effort to propagandize the war. Mentioning the movie producer Jerry Bruckheimer (who made the film of my book "Black Hawk Down"), the BBC suggested the heroic tale was invented by Pentagon spinmeisters.
This makes for a juicy theory, but it isn't likely. For one thing, it would hardly have taken a secret plot to get the American press to make a hero out of Lynch. What happened often happens on big breaking stories, especially from a war zone. The bits and pieces of information that emerge from the fog are fit into a familiar frame.
There are two parts to this supposed propaganda coup. The first deals with Lynch's capture: whether she fought or was injured when her vehicle crashed. The second deals with the rescue: whether her rescuers engaged in a fierce firefight or staged the whole show.
Lynch, 19, a supply clerk with the army's 507th Ordinance Maintenance Company, was captured on March 23, when her unit made a wrong turn near the Iraqi city of An Nasiriyah. Nine soldiers from her unit were killed. Video images of dead soldiers and terrified captives from her unit were a shock to American viewers early in the conflict, when there were fears that the war effort was bogged down. So Lynch's rescue 10 days later gave a big lift to American morale. "Saving Private Lynch" was the Big Story.
But if the Pentagon was really attempting to sell a Hollywood scenario, they fell badly short. At his briefing, Brigadier General Vincent Brooks said that Lynch had been "retrieved," not rescued. He showed a videotape consisting of a brief muddy clip through a green night vision lens showing special operations soldiers carrying her on a stretcher from a Black Hawk helicopter.
If the Pentagon had wanted to manufacture a bogus firefight surely they could have done better.
In fact, Brooks acknowledged at the first briefing that there was no resistance inside the hospital. He said there had been gunfights going in and coming out, but did not characterize them as fierce.
There is no doubt that the American media took these bits and pieces from the fog of war and assembled them into a heroic tale. This is how the media works today, for better or worse. It happens without any prompting from the Pentagon.
It will be a while before what really happened to the ill-fated 507th is known. War is like that. Until then, we'll have to settle for the tendency to weave what little we know into a familiar shape - often one resembling the narrative arc of a film.
Mark Bowden, author of "Black Hawk Down," is a correspondent for The Atlantic Monthly and a columnist for The Philadelphia Inquirer.