Stewart Schooley vient de nous annoncer :
You think this photo is funny? Saddam was a monster, that's ok... But
remember me how much people were killed with him, and how many since
the second war in Iraq? If you don't have the information, here it is:
more than 300.000 death and even more wounded persons... When shall we
have the pleasure to see a stupid image with Bush's cat?
To answer your questions:
1. Yes it is funny.
2.Your figures are accurate but as for those in Iraq who are Islamic
terrorists... not nearly enough are dead.
3. Probably not till long after we see Chirac's.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
You think this photo is funny? Saddam was a monster, that's ok... But
remember me how much people were killed with him, and how many since
the second war in Iraq? If you don't have the information, here it is:
more than 300.000 death and even more wounded persons... When shall we
have the pleasure to see a stupid image with Bush's cat?
Andy a émis l'idée suivante :
I never say I'm proud about French Foreign Politic, but when I answer
to someone, I have have at less the courtesy not to offend him. On the
other hand if offends me, I have no reason to be kind with him.
If I am not proud of French Foreign Politic, I recognize however that
France is far from having supported so many dictators that the USA did
(and does), shot down so many rising democracies to settle bastards in
the head of bloodthirsty regimes. France did not make either Ben Laden
and Al Qaida, etc....
Then my small son of bitch, I fought in the Middle East, in the Chad
and in the Lebanon, helped to evacuate some american people which
pissed ofbecause the fear in their trousers while you vomited your
tepid beer in a pub, hidden well far from there. So you keep your
insults of surrender in your underpants, that will make at least
something which fidgets in this place!
I'm not piling on against the French - but there was that little gift of
Vietnam France gave the US, when we may have otherwise backed Ho Chi Minh.
WmB
Le [Jour] 18/01/2007, WmB a écrit :
This history is more complicate than that, but you are not wrong.
Indochina, and later Viet-Nam was an enormous bullshit, like all the
colonies. My opinion is each people need to be sovereign in his own
country.
The US was instrumental in making sure that Indochina was given back to
the French after WWII. Ho Chi Minh was a hero fighting against the
Japanese to that point. With the French withdrawal, it was an American
decision to take up arms for Viet Nam or not. Can't blame the French for
that, realistically.
For a really amazing what-if, how about if the US supported and rebuilt
a US friendly Republic of Viet Nam in 1945 instead of supporting a
colonial power? I would be most interested in hearing Chris's (flying
frog) opinion on this.
--- Stephen
Stephen Tontoni vient de nous annoncer :
Well Stephen, I really don't know. Like I wrote it, I think all
colonial powers are crime against humanity, French one like the other
ones. So, for me, Indochina had no reason to exist like that, but only
with a status of free country.
Well yeah, I didn't say they held a gun to our head - but if I recall my
history correctly the French (and the British) were pretty damned adamant
about re-establishing their prewar control over their territories. At a time
when the US was coming to the realization that nationalization was
ultimately unavoidable - cite, Philippine indpendence.
So I make the point that the US deferred to its most recent and traditional
ally in France, rather than acting in its own national interests immediately
after WWII. I realize the equation is little bit more complex than all
that, and I would not wish to portray US motives as completely sterling and
lacking any self-indulgence, but for the immediate future after WWII,
Indochina was for the most part a French problem of their own choosing -
that the US would soon inherit when a decade later Vietnam became for all
intents and purposes the southern shoulder of the Asian firebreak against
Cold War communist expansion.
The original criticism I replied to was that the US has made some strange
bedfellows over the years to the point other countries, like France, have
much cleaner hands. I say - not so fast. Sometimes we lie in beds, if
others did not make, they certainly had a hand in arranging the furniture.
French Indochina.
WmB
Le [Jour] 18/01/2007, WmB a écrit :
Ok, thanks
Yes, I know that, but the word "terrosriste" and "terrorisme" (easy to
understand, English words are the same except the "e" ) at the endwere
created during WWII to speak about French guerilleros. We called these
people "resistants", they called the same ones "terroristes".
Yep, true. In Limousin, my region, it was not only in 1944... they died
there all along the war. In savoy also, and in general in regions with
mountains. People of these regions are used to hard life, not like in
the cities, and they wasn't afraid to suffer to kill all the enemies
they can, to free their country. They was used to eat just a few (or no
eat during some days), walk long times in hard conditions, to not
sleep, etc... Their head are harder than that of any Nazi soldier...
;-)
No, just "heros ordinaires" (common heros) like we say here, that is
normal people who were obliged by the life and to remain human beings,
simply , to act in hero.
Yes, right. However, I do not forget that some French have acts exactly
similar in Algeria. I am nevertheless a former paratrooper, but I do
not admit that soldiers can worse than animals, by forgetting what
means word "honor"!
I hope that.. but I'm not sure... Too many ultra-nationalist movments
in Europe today... The future seems really dark there.
Chris:
You are a man of honor! And rightly proud of your service. The thing some
people forget on this board is that it is possible to disagree yet remain
civil and friends!
Hub
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PolyTech Forum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.