I am a nut over WW II movies and I have just finished watching "Midway" for the umpteenth time. I consider this the best WW II movie ever made. What are your opinions about films covering from WW I to the present? I subscribe to Netflix who claim to have a 18000 volume of DVDs for rent. TIA Pete
WW II Moveis
Apr 17, 2004
196 Replies
Uhhhh. the best?
I suggest these instead:
Patton Saving Pvt. Ryan Battleground Pearl Harbor (FX only!!!!!!!!) no flame on that one please Tora, Tora,Tora (from which Midway stole from endlessly) Casablanca Das Boot Thirty Seconds Over Tokyo Guadalcanal Diary Best Years of Our Lives
I hope Netflix has more than just Midway...
Craig
"Das Boot" - without question the best submarine movie ever made, and probably the best of the WWII genre as well.
Das Boot. Makes quite a point...
Always enjoyed (?!?) Tora Tora Tora (or if you can only watch kosher, Torah Torah Torah... hey, it had to be said.)
Saving Private Ryan was interesting. As was Sink the Bismark and Battle of Britain.
I'm sure others will come to mind when I'm not at a keyboard.
I vote for Das Boot, The Enemy Below, Sink the Bismark, Tora Tora Tora, and the Great Escape although it doesn;t have much battle sequence in it. It is still in the time frame. Midway is ok, but the errors are too much for me to really enjoy it. Especially when Heston crashes in an SBD and they show footage of a Panther I believe crashing on deck, come on a jet substituting for a WWII prop dive bomber? Steve
i vote dam busters for best wartime made movie.
Didn't they use the same footage in The Hunt for Red October? I'm sure it was a Panther crashing on deck in that movie. hard to believe there is no more recent footage of a crash on deck...
Craig
damn. forgot all about that one. its the only war movie the wife will sit thru with me. great mix of science and action. it works all the way thru.
Craig
Since I am several days into watching the History Channel's "Band of Brothers" I'll put my vote in for that.
Considering the fact that it has been so long since WWII the German vehicles alone are incredible. The C-47 drop scenes are breathtaking.
I worked on "Tora!3", but I'm one of the few that really enjoyed Pearl Harbor. Worked on "Memphis Belle" and some of it really pissed me off. We had to fight the continuity people to keep the bathing buty red on one side, blue on the other. They finally caved, then had crew at altitude leaning against the inside fuselage with bare hands and chatting without O2 masks. Personally I liked the original better. :-)
Then there was "Radio Flyer", but the less said about that turkey the better.
Tom
love the flak from the dam towers. some poor guy musta got eyestrain making those scratches in the film. best scene was the real life dialogue at the end of barnes wallis saying if he'd known the cost, he'd bever started. haven't seen it on dvd.
One of my favourites is Stalag 17, along with The Great Escape, seeing as it became the annual Christmas movie while growing up, and kept me out the way of parents ;)
"Pork Chop Hill"....now there's a movie!
-John
There is also one I belive is called "Fighter Squadron" with a lot of P-47 action over Europe.
Craig, I'm surprised you didn't mention "Battle of Britain." "Midway" lifted a number of aerial scenes from there as well.
Andy
For the First World War, I'd add "All Quiet on the Western Front" (Lew Ayres version, not John-Boy), "Blue Max" (for the aerial scenes) and "Beyond Victory" (a real old British piece with Cary Grant from about 1935 or so with some good aerial footage). There was a silent that I saw years ago with my folks about the Army Air Service, with Buddy Rogers, but I can't remember its name. Used 1920s aircraft in place of WWI aircraft, except for one Fokker (bad guy's plane)
-- John The history of things that didn't happen has never been written. . - - - Henry Kissinger
Man, if you consider "Midway" the best, how bad is the one you consider the worst????
How could you guys forget Wings,winner of the first academy award?
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required