OT: Who Made the ugliest Aircraft

Dec 06, 2003 55 Replies

Amiot 143, hands down, although Farmans should get a mention for group effort.

Bill Banaszak, MFE

So is a ball peen hammer. They ain't pretty either.

WmB

To reply, get the HECK out of there snipped-for-privacy@earthlink.net

Gee I must agree that some British navy aircraft such as the Avro Bison and Blackburn Blackburn were ungainly, yet it is a fine line between a functional utilitarian craft and something that is butt ugly!

Another factor is engineering knowledge of the times. Sure the French aircraft of the early 30's were ugly but they latched onto all metal aircraft construction quicker than other European nations. The functionality of the construction took precedence over aerodynamics. Later when their industry focused on aerodynamics they designed some of the best looking craft of the 40's

Cases in point:

Amiot 143 looked like a flying trashcan Amiot 470 series looked like a chromed bullet with wings

Of course Air & Space magazine did a 10 ugliest issue, my favorite of the 10 was the Farman 120 Jabiru. One look and you have to say to yourself "What were they thinking?" It looks as if the craft was designed so that it could be built in a walk in closet!

Check em out:

formatting link
Keith Walker

Gee I must agree that some British navy aircraft such as the Avro Bison and Blackburn Blackburn were ungainly, yet it is a fine line between a functional utilitarian craft and something that is butt ugly!

Another factor is engineering knowledge of the times. Sure the French aircraft of the early 30's were ugly but they latched onto all metal aircraft construction quicker than other European nations. The functionality of the construction took precedence over aerodynamics. Later when their industry focused on aerodynamics they designed some of the best looking craft of the 40's

Cases in point:

Amiot 143 looked like a flying trashcan Amiot 470 series looked like a chromed bullet with wings

Of course Air & Space magazine did a 10 ugliest issue, my favorite of the 10 was the Farman 120 Jabiru. One look and you have to say to yourself "What were they thinking?" It looks as if the craft was designed so that it could be built in a walk in closet!

Check em out:

formatting link
Keith Walker

Craig typed in:

You definitely don't know the type classifications! The "Dung Beetle" is the Kubelwagen with the tow behind or push ahead field toilet facility. It is not an aircraft and in the field it was proven to not be worth a sh*t. You could smell it coming for many kilometers.

Oxmoron1

Ew! Ick! Geez! Did that *fly???*

I thought that the general agreement was that the Fairey Barracuda was the ugliest aircraft ever built, but it's a comparative beauty next to some of the aircraft in the above posts. Personally, I've always thought that the butt-ugliest (and most appropriately named) plane is the XF-85 Goblin.

IIRC, that was set up for gunnery training for bomber crews.....

In article , EGMcCann writes

That would make sense. As a concept: the aircraft was something else.

Come 1940, though, lots of rather desperate defence ideas were being mooted. Strafing the length of an invasion beach at low level at the speed of a Lysander would seem to fall into that category.

After a bit of a hunt, found a page for it...

formatting link
A nice site with lots of other uglies and oddities. I was taken with the German re-built Spitfire, and the Liberator with the nose of a Fortress.

I vote for the Fairey Gannet.

Or the Shackleton. I saw one last week, and my first thought was "is that a Russian design?"

Bit unfair - what variant ?

The mark I was quite pretty. Then they added lots of EW gear and it started looking odd. Great website at

formatting link
to keep this ON topic :-)

My vote's on the X-29. They put the cockpit on the wrong end in assembly :-)

Peter

Ugly Aircraft? Budd Connestoga? Avro Shackleton? Gun turret Lysander?

I don't know, they all look pretty good in comparison to some aircraft. As far as I'm concerned, the bar is set by the British Fleet Shadower aircraft:

formatting link
Designed as in the thirties as carrier bourne observation aircraft, aesthetics and streamlining were put aside for endurance and short takeoff. Prototypes were build by two companies: Airspeed, with the A.S.39:
formatting link
with the wings folded:
formatting link
and General Aircraft Ltd, with the G.A.L.38:
formatting link
Now, I won't guarantee that they were the ugliest aircraft of all time, but they set the benchmark.

Jon.

Handsome is as handsome does. The Swordfish looked pretty homely until you got in the air with it.

Is it more,or is that a 50s chopper (from a certain company we wont mention)missing it's rotor?I kinda like it

It was a Mk II or III. The angular nose, in combination with the color (light blue) and the font used for the lettering looked Russian to me. It looked so different to the Lancaster (again the nose, and the engine nacelles) that I didn't make the connection.

Not so bad, gaze at this from the same site

formatting link
for some Bellanca C-27 uglyness

or

formatting link
Nothing like the Amiot 143. Built with ugly sticks, not just hit with it.

** mike **

Didn't the Germans have a little tracked robotic bomb called that to? Seemed to recall they first used them at Anzio? Mike IPMS

I hate to admit it but I kinda like it... It's like a streetcar stapped under a skinny airplane.

This one one is my favorite for "just plane ugly"

formatting link

It's certainly a dainty little thing compared with its predecessor, the Bennett (or Waitomo) Airtruck. I'm definitely considering doing a scratchbuild in 1/48; the real thing used Harvard parts reassembled, and it's tempting to do the same with a Monogram T-6 kit.

Tony P

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required